We're at the time of year when we watch the transition from one season to another. Seasonal change isn't the only thing in the air.

Signaling the completion of a long journey towards secularism, the University of Notre Dame announced a "refreshed" set of staff values in late October, rolling out language that sounds suspiciously like the same corporate boilerplate used everywhere from Silicon Valley startups to mid-level insurance firms.

Community. Collaboration. Excellence. Innovation.

It's a list that reads like something printed, laminated, and handed out at an onboarding meeting. On the surface, it reads like a sterilized index that HR and focus groups spent months working on. However, a quiet omission sits underneath all of it: the staff requirement to "support the Catholic mission" no longer appears.

Insisting that the mission remains woven through every part of campus life, the university erased the explicit phrasing. It's an old and familiar chill felt by anyone who pays attention to American universities: the consistent drift into ideological rewiring.

The details from a Campus Reform report illustrate the changes. The original staff-value list included "Leadership in Mission: Understands, accepts, and supports the Catholic mission of the university." The updated version? Not so much.

Further, a Fox News report includes a university statement that claims the Catholic mission remains foundational and unchanged, saying the language shift reflects a broader cultural weaving rather than a point-in-time directive.

The thin explanation offsets a traditional mindset: when institutions deeply believe in something, they say it plainly, carve it into stone, build statues around it, and defend it with consistency, clarity, and pride.

When plain-spoken disappears, it hints at a silence behind deeper motivations: before any honest debate can take place, softened language is often the first step in retreat.

It's a familiar shift to anyone who studied what happened after the 1967 Land O'Lakes Statement, when many Catholic universities declared independence from Church governance and Catholic identity slowly became cultural décor rather than a lived mission.

A Catholic University That No Longer Says Catholic Out Loud

Marketing itself as a Catholic beacon, Notre Dame sat proudly behind its academic rigor, national influence, and deep roots, a Catholic university providing more than theology courses and campus hymns, shaping moral imagination, and forming students through the lens of a faith that has built hospitals, orphanages, missions, and entire intellectual traditions over centuries. Unsurprisingly, when a Catholic school stops using Catholic vocabulary in its operational language, there's a reordering of priorities.

Administrators claim that the Catholic mission remains a core principle. But words matter.

Decisions removing explicit language don't happen by accident. Staff committees debate the wording in paragraphs for months; consultants draft language, while university officials review any edits. Nothing simply slips out.

Highlighting corporate themes rather than religious ones reflects cultural pressure from a faculty and administrative class that leans heavily toward progressivism.

That same class often treats religion as something quaint or optional, great for branding, but unwelcome in daily routines. This shift aligns perfectly with a trend across many prestigious institutions that once carried strong religious identities.

When a prominent Catholic university treats its mission as nothing more than an optional footnote, it opens the door to deeper dilution: changes in faculty hiring, shifting curricula, and drifting student-life programming. University partnerships pick up ideological weight. Donors who care about Catholic identity immediately sense the shift, while families who pay steep tuition for authentic Catholic formation end up with a campus that mirrors Northwestern more closely than one founded by the Congregation of the Holy Cross.

The Power of the Radical Left in the Academy

Obviously, the leftward tilt of higher education wasn't something that happened overnight: Progressive activism dug in deeper than a tick on a hound.

First through student-life offices and then through administrative layers, DEI mandates and faculty-hiring committees now treat ideological alignment with a seriousness once reserved for scholarship.

Nobody should be surprised when institutions like Harvard or Yale present secular frameworks — those campuses abandoned their Christian roots generations ago, a path Notre Dame never claimed. It sold a different story, building its identity around Catholic Tradition, scholarship, intellectual life, and moral anchoring.

That identity attracted kids who wanted something firmer than shifting cultural currents, and a decision removing the clearest staff-value statement directly linked to the Catholic mission shows just how far ideological pressure extends.

Power in universities works quietly. Administrators rarely announce, "We decided to un-Catholic the place." Instead, they present gentle phrases, promising continuity, inclusive excellence, global citizenship, and shared responsibility.

When the radical left achieves influence in a place like Notre Dame, the symbolism carries serious national weight. Americans see a Catholic flagship bending towards ideological conformity, with prestige and pressure overriding tradition. Once, Americans viewed faith-anchored universities as cultural stabilizers, a role weakened when institutions themselves adopt the language of secular corporatism.

Why It Matters

A Catholic university can't remain Catholic by implication — it would be like me, standing inside a garage, calling myself a car. A mission doesn't survive by osmosis; it survives through clear articulation, repetition, courage, and adherence. The Catholic identity of Notre Dame shaped generations of American leaders, scholars, priests, scientists, athletes, and public servants, building a reputation for serious faith and academics. A school with such a history starts softening its language around the most essential part of identity, and the long-term consequences become predictable.

A cultural vacuum doesn't remain empty for long; progressive ideology fills every available space, expanding bureaucracy, and retracts religious language. Students receive something like Catholic-lite formation filtered through political trends. A university's future is changing, and it's starting to resemble every other elite institution that surrendered its anchor long ago.

For generations, Catholic families have trusted Notre Dame, while donors have funded chapels, scholarships, and programs because they believe in the mission. Alumni longed for a place that held firm while other schools drifted, and now they confront a moment where the institution they loved tests the boundaries of a new reality.

Notre Dame's leaders can reverse course, restore explicit Catholic language, defend the Catholic character that has given the university its strength, and publicly reaffirm their mission.

A Catholic university should never be embarrassed by its own foundation, never fear the opinions of administrators who treat faith as an institutional liability. Instead, a Catholic university should lead with clarity rather than hide behind "refreshed values."

Notre Dame needs to speak with certainty if it still believes in Catholic identity. Catholic Tradition deserves a voice that stands tall, instead of using phrases that look good on a laminated HR card.

Final Thoughts

Rarely do Catholic institutions collapse overnight; instead, they slowly erode one value statement, one curriculum shift, and one administrative edit at a time. Standing at a crossroads, Notre Dame's decision to remove explicit Catholic language highlights a larger struggle for the soul of American education. If the school wants to honor the foundation that built its reputation, its leaders need to clearly articulate the mission, live it faithfully, and fiercely protect it.

Notre Dame can't trade clarity for trendiness and expect its identity to survive. Life doesn't work that way.

To keep strong reporting alive, support the work that exposes how elite institutions shift, drift, and sometimes surrender core values. 

Join PJ Media VIP for deep analysis, investigative originals, and commentary that refuses to bow to the cultural trends reshaping American life.