The Mamdani Nightmare Is Just Beginning

Analysis of Zohran Mamdani's policies and their impact on New Yorkers, focusing on property taxes and income redistribution.

You'd never know it from how I write, but I actually am a sensitive soul (my wife jokes that I am not the "strong, silent" type but rather the "weak and effusive" type), so my heart really does bleed when I see ordinary people harmed by the policies that they admittedly voted for. 

Advertisement

I don't look at voters in Blue cities and states and just say, "Well, you voted for it," when I see Portland and San Francisco citizens suffer under the policies imposed on them from above. 

Admittedly, part of the reason I don't think that is that I know that a good chunk of the residents DIDN'T actually vote for it. Cities in particular are basically run by political machines made up of public employees, leftist unions, and activist groups, and voter turnout in local elections tends to be much lower than in national ones. It's more of a cabal than an electorate that installs politicians, although admittedly, there are an awful lot of people outside those groups who just automatically vote Democrat. 

Still, even cities have middle classes, Independents, and even some Republicans, and they are pure victims, as are the children who live in crime-ridden neighborhoods and go to poor schools. There are millions of people who are being victimized simply because they grew up in and live in cities that are run by lefty political machines. 

Advertisement

Ironically, Zohran Mamdani may have a stronger mandate than most mayors of Democratic cities. New York City can and has elected centrist mayors, perhaps because it is a huge city with a larger-than-normal middle and working class. But I still feel bad for the people who Mamdani is going to screw, and boy is he going to screw them good and hard. 

He ran as a "Democratic Socialist," so it should come as no surprise to anybody who doesn't automatically assume that PolitiFact actually tells the truth, that he is a communist, but apparently, even some of his supporters are shocked that he is planning to seize their money, not just other people's. 

Advertisement

Mamdani is complaining that his budget, which is larger than the State of Florida's, isn't fully funded, so he has to raid pension funds (Chicago!) and raise taxes. 

It's not because he wants to improve city services. He seems uninterested in ensuring garbage is picked up or snow removed; his goal is income redistribution, and the best way to do that is take from those who have and give it to those who don't. And if his voters are among the ones who have, they must give it up.

You'd never know it if you didn't get outside Manhattan, but the city actually has a lot of homeowners, and most of them are not wealthy. Real estate is, of course, expensive, but still over 30% of people own, and often those homes have been in families for years. Hiking property taxes will hit a slice of the working class pretty hard. 

Advertisement

I'm also pretty sure the Mamdani approach to criminal justice will have a strong impact. We tend to think of New York as crime-ridden, but compared to other big Blue cities, it really isn't. Soon it will be. 

I doubt that people will like what is coming. 

Mamdani's "man of the people" shtick is, as it always is with communists, a complete lie. Communism always creates a nomenklatura, fixates on oppressing "enemies of the people," and in the end destroys whatever it touches. 

Ask the Cubans or Venezuelans about that, or any of those Russian emigres who live in Brighton Beach. At least the ones who aren't in organized crime. 

Advertisement

Ordinary New Yorkers are going to get a lesson in just how badly things are run by communists, and what it means to drive out capital. In the end, it is the middle and working classes who suffer the most. A lot of them knew that even before Mamdani was elected. He didn't exactly kill it in the working-class vote

Democrats appeal to the consciences of the upper, non-entrepreneurial class and to the lower classes who want more stuff. People who do work for a living or who create wealth through investment know better. Unfortunately, it's only the latter who can vote with their feet. 

That's why my heart bleeds for the former. They are going to get screwed. 

Editor's note: If we thought our job in pushing back against the Academia/media/Democrat censorship complex was over with the election, think again. This is going to be a long fight. If you want to join the conversation in the comments -- and support independent platforms -- why not join our VIP Membership program? Choose VIP to support Hot Air and access our premium content, VIP Gold to extend your access to all Townhall Media platforms and participate in this show, or VIP Platinum to get access to even more content and discounts on merchandise. Use the promo code FIGHT to join or to upgrade your existing membership level today, and get 60% off!


David Strom

749 Blog posts

Comments