www.newsbusters.org
CNN's Cornish Invites Trump 'Doomsday ' Author To Paint Horror Picture Of 'Gestapo'-like ICE
Does Audie Cornish not realize that some viewers will discover just how rabidly anti-Trump her expert of the day is--or doesn't she care?
To discuss the plan to increase by 10,000 the number of ICE agents, on Thursday's CNN This Morning, Cornish brought in Garrett Graff, innocuously portrayed as just a "journalist."
Graff was a former staffer on Howard Dean's presidential campaign, and had stints at Politico and Washingtonian magazine.
But his main gig now is "Doomsday Scenario," a website that describes itself as "Trying to answer if things are as bad as they seem." The "doomsday" in question is the Trump presidency, and, yes, things aren't just as bad as they seem—they're worse!
Sample headlines include: "Today, Right Now, is the Easiest Moment To Draw the Line Against Donald Trump."
And in the context of his chat with Cornish, Graff also wrote: "Four Fears about ICE, Trump's New Masked Monster."
Graff began by analogizing ICE agents to Hitler's Gestapo. So Trump's ICE is a masked monster, unleashing Gestapo-like agents! Yup, just the kind of fair 'n balanced expert right up CNN's alley! No one "fact checks it. Daniel Dale's on vacation.
Graff claimed that many people "are going to start feeling like they need to carry their passports and their birth certificates to go down to the grocery store." That fear was echoed by CNN Senior White House Reporter Betsy Klein, a member of the Group Chat:
"I think it's a really massive concern for any American who is a person of color."
ICE is the Gestapo and it's racist! CNN commentator Sabrina Singh fretted that ICE will be "going to go after people that have been in this country for 30 years."
A favorite liberal media tactic is to find the most heart-wrenching example to make its case. But before citing the example of the arrest of a grandfather with two sons in the Marines, Singh turned to former Trump White House communications director Mike Dubke and claimed,
"I'm by no means saying that we shouldn't enforce our immigration laws, but . . . "
Right.
When Dubke finally got a say, he injected sense into the discussion:
"I see an answer to an election that we just had . . . The American people wanted that southern border secured, also wanted something done about the millions of illegal migrants that have come into this country over the last several years, and this is an answer to that."
May Graff hear those words. But Graff warned that by having to quickly hire so many new agents, ICE will have to "cut hiring standards, cut educational standards. There are going to be thousands of people selected into ICE who would not have been hired in the normal pace of applications."
So, for purposes of meeting DEI/affirmative action goals, does Graff oppose lowering standards for hiring people or admitting them to college? Somehow, we doubt it.
For purposes of the interview, Graff had been conveniently situated in front of a wall adorned with Nixon and Goldwater signs [see screencap] that could have misled viewers into imagining that he had Republican sympathies. In fact, as mentioned, he worked on Howard Dean's presidential campaign, and is rabidly anti-Trump. In 2022, he wrote a Watergate history widely praised by liberals.
And whereas the chyron described Dubke as a former Trump aide, Singh was cast merely as a former Deputy Pentagon Press Secretary—omitting that she served in the Biden administration.
Here's the transcript.
CNN This Morning
7/17/25
6:17 am EDT
GARRETT GRAFF: America has never been a, you know, papers-please country before. We associate that with the Gestapo, or fascist Italy or the Soviet-era Iron Curtain.
And there are a lot of people in America who are going to start feeling like they need to carry their passports and their birth certificates to go down to the grocery store.
AUDIE CORNISH: ICE now becomes one of the highest-funded federal law enforcement agencies in the country, all thanks, of course, to the president's new spending bill. It's giving ICE the ability to hire more and arrest more.
TOM HOMAN: We do have collateral arrests in in many areas because we're out looking for those public safety threats, but we're going to enforce immigration law, too.
CORNISH: So, with all the hiring of new agents and the billions of federal dollars now at their disposal, critics are raising concerns about whether ICE could, in fact, end up growing too big too fast.
That's what I discuss on this week's Assignment with journalist Garrett Graff. He's actually been tracking the growth of ICE and ICE activity across the country for years.
GRAFF: I think one of the things that we're starting to see very quickly is ICE, for most of its 20-year history, has gone after, quote-unquote, bad criminals. Gang members, drug cartel members, people associated with violent crime in the United States.
That's really resource-intensive. And to meet the numbers that the White House is demanding, 3,000 people a day, ICE has to go after America's grandmas. You know, they have to go after the easiest low-hanging fruit that they can find.
CORNISH: ICE has to grow under the new law by 10,000 new agents. What are the dangers of growing that big that fast?
GRAFF: A big part of the challenge is, any law enforcement agency that has ever had a surge like this in the past has had to cut hiring standards, cut training standards, cut educational standards, and cut supervision standards of new agents in order to meet those hiring quotas.
Because, in very simple terms, hiring 10,000 agents in the next two years means that there are going to be thousands of people selected into ICE who would not have been hired in the normal pace of applications right now.
. . .
CORNISH: I'm just wondering about this concern he's raising. What did you hear, Betsy?
BETSY KLEIN: Oh, I think it's a really massive concern for any American who is a person of color, who is the collateral damage that we saw Tom Homan talk about. It's a really serious issue for Americans who are living in these areas where they're seeing this kind of enforcement.
. . .
SABRINA SINGH: I also think what was interesting that Garrett raised, and that's known, is that they're being asked to make quotas. And these are quotas on people. This isn't like parking tickets. We're talking about quotas on arresting and rounding up and deporting people. And what's happening is exactly what Garrett said, is that they're going to go after people that have been in this country for 30 years.
And I'm by no means saying that we shouldn't enforce our immigration laws, but when you have a story of a grandfather who has three sons, two of which are serving in the Marines, being pulled and arrested by ICE agents, is that really a good use of resources and funding?
CORNISH: What do you see in kind of what Garrett's talking about?
MIKE DUBKE: Well, I see an answer to an election that we just had, in which immigration and border control was one of the major topics, if not one of the top two topics, for the election.
The American people wanted that southern border secured, also wanted something done about the millions of illegal migrants that have come into this country over the last several years, and this is an answer to that.