www.newsbusters.org
CNN's Hill Tosses Softballs To Providence Mayor On Brown University Shooting & Aftermath
This past Tuesday, ten days after the December 13th shooting at Brown University, and on the same day that Brown placed its' Police Chief Rodney Chatman on administrative leave, and the U.S. Department of Education announced an investigation into safety procedures at Brown, Providence Mayor Brett Smiley was interviewed on CNN, and was tossed softballs on the latest developments.
Smiley appeared on CNN News Central and could have been hit with legitimate, tough, probing questions and follow-ups on the shootings, and security at Brown, the news on Chief Chatman, as well as Smiley's own performance during the aftermath of the shooting. But Host Erica Hill failed to provide much of what could have and should have been delivered. Even her lead-in into the interview fell short. "School officials say they have placed the campus Police Chief, Rodney Chatman, on administrative leave, effective immediately as the school reviews the response to the attack. Now, according to an announcement a former Providence, Rhode Island Police Chief will now lead a review into what happened..."
Hill made no mention of the fact that this was not the first time in his career that Chatman has been placed on leave. It happened to him at University of Utah, shortly before being asked to leave, and winding up at Brown. It should have been her first question for the Mayor. It wasn't.
HILL: When we look at where things stand, understandable there would be this after-action report by the school. We're also learning about the Department of Education investigation into Brown. Do you believe that's appropriate and warranted?
SMILEY: ...Brown has been entirely open and would have, without having been asked, conducted this after-action review, and the city of Providence is going to do the same as well. I'm extraordinarily proud of the work of my department through this process, but that doesn't mean that we shouldn't be willing to look at what we might have done better, what tools and technology we might have wished we had, and Brown's willing to ask all those same questions as well, which is what the campus community deserves, just like it's what my residents deserve.
That was it from Hill on the entire subject of the Brown Police Chief and his replacement, although the Mayor would bring it up himself later. Then Hill pitched another softball.
HILL: I understand that you've reached out to some other mayors who have unfortunately faced similar circumstances. Have they offered you any guidance you found helpful in terms of what needs to be examined for these after-action reports?
SMILEY: I'm very active in the U.S. Conference of Mayors, and through that network, they have been reaching out....The other good advice that I'm getting from my colleagues around the country, because sadly, so many of America's mayors have been through some version of this type of violence, is to make sure that we're staying on the right track in terms of helping, helping our community both heal from what happened and providing resources in terms of trauma and PTSD...
HILL: Yes, it will certainly be important to stay on top of that, understandably.
Hill's toughest question came on the issue of cameras, or lack thereof, inside and outside of the building on campus where the shooting took place.
HILL: If we're thinking about the perimeter, right, of a college campus and where it blends into or sort of becomes the city of Providence, shouldn't those perimeters be a place where there should be, perhaps, added surveillance?
SMILEY: I'm sure that's something that Brown will look at. And you mentioned at the outset, the new acting Chief [Hugh Clements] at Brown is our former Police Chief, which is someone that I know well and have a really high degree of confidence in...And so, I know he'll ask those questions. And -- and I have confidence in the administration at Brown that they'll implement recommendations that need to be implemented.
Smiley's next statement should have raised a red flag for Hill, but it did not.
SMILEY: ..Brown is a campus that is integrated with our community here in Providence. It's one of the things we love about it. Neighbors walk their dog through campus. I live nearby, I jog through campus regularly. I did so this morning. I hope this doesn't turn into a situation where the campus is walled off or gated off. That's not going to help the situation... So, we should be using technology in a smart way that'll help make everyone safer...
Sure, just let everyone enter the campus, because that has worked out so well. And they can waive at any new cameras that appear. We know that the Brown shooter had no trouble coming and going many times. But Hill apparently heard nothing worth following up on, and thanked the Mayor for his time. Or maybe she knew his jogging schedule, and didn't want to keep him from "integrating the community."