Biblical Theology Is for Nerds
Favicon 
www.thegospelcoalition.org

Biblical Theology Is for Nerds

When Frodo stands before the Council of Elrond, learning how his uncle’s ring connects to an ancient story of darkness and hope, he’s experiencing something similar to what happens when we discover how Isaiah’s prophecies illuminate Christ’s coming. When Marvel fans piece together the interconnected stories of the MCU across multiple films, they’re exercising the same muscles needed to trace biblical themes from Genesis to Revelation. The skills that make someone an expert in Star Wars lore or DC Comics continuity might be preparing him or her for something far more profound: biblical theology. Scripture’s Complex Storyline Biblical theology is more than just studying the Bible—it’s a specific approach to understanding Scripture that uncovers how the entire Bible fits together as one unified story. As Andrew Naselli explains, it’s the practice of analyzing and synthesizing the Bible’s organic, salvation-historical connections across the whole canon, especially focusing on how the Old and New Testaments progress, integrate, and ultimately culminate in Christ. Unlike systematic theology, which organizes biblical teachings by topic, biblical theology traces the development of themes and promises as they unfold through Scripture’s historical narrative. It helps us see how earlier parts of the Bible lay the groundwork that later parts build on, creating an awe-inspiring tapestry of divine revelation. This approach to Scripture might seem daunting. Yet for those immersed in “nerd culture”—particularly the world of science fiction, fantasy, and comics—the journey into biblical theology could feel surprisingly familiar. When we talk about nerd culture in this context, we’re not referring to every aspect of what might be considered “nerdy” but specifically to the shared interests, activities, and reading practices that have emerged around these particular media forms. For those immersed in ‘nerd culture,’ the journey into biblical theology could feel surprisingly familiar. These are readers and viewers who have developed sophisticated skills of analysis: They trace complex storylines across volumes, engage with detailed world-building, and discover how seemingly minor details become crucial plot points. Consider the fan who can explain how The Silmarillion enriches every page of The Lord of the Rings, making seemingly minor details resonate with deeper significance. These practices go far beyond simple entertainment—they represent a particular way of reading that requires patience, attention to detail, and the ability to hold multiple storylines in tension while looking for meaningful connections. From Fandom to Faith The shared characteristics between nerd-culture media and biblical reading reveal why this connection works so naturally. Each rewards careful attention to prophetic foreshadowing and detailed world-building. Both present grand narratives that unfold across multiple books, with seemingly minor details becoming crucial to the story’s conclusion. This parallel extends beyond just reading practices to the way communities engage with these texts. The skills developed in parsing complex fictional universes can translate directly to biblical-theological reading. If you can track the complex relationships between X-Men characters across decades of comics, you’re developing the skills to understand the intricate associations between Old Testament prophets and their New Testament fulfillment. If you can appreciate how The Lord of the Rings weaves multiple storylines toward a final resolution, you’re preparing to see how Scripture weaves diverse genres and authors into one coherent testimony about Christ. Naselli illustrates this connection with a familiar example: When you read a masterful story like Harry Potter, the first time you read it is special because you are enjoying a spellbinding storyline. But the subsequent times you read the story can be even more significant because you can start tracing thematic trajectories that you were unable to detect in your first reading. That illustrates how we do biblical theology. As we read the Bible over and over and over, we can better trace thematic trajectories and make connections that the divine author brilliantly designed. This insight leads us to consider how we might intentionally apply these parallel skills to Scripture study. Practical Applications God often prepares his people for deeper scriptural engagement through unexpected means, and the analytical skills developed through years of engaging with complex fictional universes may be one such divine preparation. The transition from fandom expertise to biblical-theological study, therefore, may only require creative tweaks to help readers apply their abilities to reading Scripture’s unified narrative. For instance, those who excel at tracking complex fictional universes can channel these abilities into meaningful Bible study through several complementary approaches. Just as fans meticulously chart Doctor Who’s chronology or map the intricate timeline of the Wheel of Time series, readers can create rich visual representations of biblical narratives. This might involve developing a “Promise Timeline” that tracks God’s covenantal promises from their first appearance through their fulfillment, beginning with the protoevangelium in Genesis 3:15 and following the development of the Abrahamic covenant to its ultimate completion in Christ. The same dedication used to track character arcs in long-running series can be applied to biblical figures and themes. For instance, readers could create theme trees that branch out from major concepts, starting with the “seed of the woman” and tracing its development through the line of Seth, Abraham’s promised offspring, David’s royal lineage, and the prophetic servant songs, culminating in Christ. This approach allows readers to trace messianic expectations as they would a major character’s development, documenting each new revelation and showing how Jesus fulfills and transcends these expectations. Just as fans compile detailed wikis for fictional universes like Narnia or Star Trek, discussion groups can create comprehensive guides to the biblical world. This might take the form of a shared document in which they explain how words and ideas develop across Scripture while putting them in their cultural and historical contexts. Concept maps can demonstrate how ideas like “kingdom,” “covenant,” and “redemption” interconnect while tracing their development across different genres and identifying recurring patterns and motifs. Traditional Bible study can even be transformed using methods familiar to fan communities through collaborative study sessions. These sessions might begin with “Previously on . . .” summaries to maintain narrative continuity, encouraging members to present discoveries and interpretations while examining how biblical authors build on earlier texts. Group members can track different themes or promises, sharing insights through collaborative documents and creating visual presentations of the connections they find. Each of these approaches can be tailored to align with specific interests and skills within study groups. Those well versed in comic book continuity might particularly appreciate tracking typological connections, while fantasy readers might naturally gravitate toward the world-building aspects of Scripture. Whatever the approach, the goal remains the same: to channel the enthusiasm and attention to detail that characterizes fan engagement into deeper biblical understanding, all while maintaining appropriate reverence for the text. Greater Story For the person who can quote every line from Dune or name every member of the Justice League, biblical theology offers an invitation to apply those same passionate analytical skills to Scripture. The reward isn’t just knowledge of an invented world but insight into the story that underlies all of reality—God’s plan of redemption through Christ. The reward isn’t just knowledge of an invented world but insight into the story that underlies all of reality. The skills that make someone a “nerd” might be God’s way of preparing him or her for deeper engagement with his Word. After all, if we can spend hours immersed in fictional universes, how much more should we desire to understand the true story that gives meaning to all others? So embrace your inner nerd. Those countless hours spent analyzing plot theories, tracking character arcs, and mapping fictional worlds haven’t been wasted. They’ve been preparing for something greater: seeing how all Scripture points to Christ, the true hero of the greatest story ever told.