White house spokesperson says administration will appeal

A U.S. District Court judge ruled Tuesday that the Trump administration’s policy of targeting foreign students and faculty for deportation based on their pro-Palestinian advocacy is unconstitutional.

The plaintiffs, a coalition of academic and civil rights groups, hailed the decision as a crucial defense of constitutional principles.

But White House spokesperson Liz Huston described the ruling as “outrageous” and said an appeal is coming, asserting the ruling hampers national security, Reuters reported.

“Studying in the United States is a privilege that the Trump administration will not allow to foreign nationals who endanger America’s national security or imperil campus safety,” Huston said.

In his 161-page decision, Judge William Young found that the administration systematically violated the First Amendment rights of foreign students and engaged in a concerted effort to “chill” free speech on campuses.

Young ruled that Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem and Secretary of State Marco Rubio implemented Trump’s executive orders “in a viewpoint-discriminatory manner to suppress protected speech, violating the First Amendment.”

“…The Public Officials’ threats to continue detaining, deporting, and revoking visas based on political speech provide circumstantial evidence of viewpoint-discriminatory enforcement that has objectively chilled Plaintiffs’ speech.”

Young also criticized the administration’s tactics, such as the use of masked agents for arrests. He also described the case as “perhaps the most important ever to fall within the jurisdiction of this district court.”

The New York Times reported that “the Trump administration’s strategy of scapegoating a few prominent leaders of pro-Palestinian demonstrations was a calculated move, designed to force like-minded academics from abroad into self-censorship.”

The ruling followed a two-week trial during which “Green card-holding professors at U.S. universities testified that the high-profile arrests of outspoken students, like former Columbia University pro-Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil and Tufts student Rümeysa Öztürk, made them fearful and stifled their speech,” The Hill reported.

MORE: Trump administration has revoked more than 6,000 student visas