In a nuanced display of moral acrobatics, progressive activists across the United States have begun updating their social media profile pictures with a new slogan: “Slava Ukraine, Unless a Homeless Black Man Kills an Innocent Ukrainian on a Train.” The change follows the tragic murder of Iryna Zarutska, a 32-year-old Ukrainian aid worker, who was fatally stabbed on a Chicago subway by a homeless Black man, prompting a swift recalibration of leftist solidarity.

The updated mantra, which began trending on X late last night, reflects what activists call a “context-sensitive approach to geopolitics.” “We’re still totally about Ukraine’s fight for freedom,” said River Willow, a barista and part-time zine curator from Seattle, as they adjusted their profile overlay to include the caveat. “But we can’t ignore the intersectional dynamics here. Like, what if the perpetrator is marginalized? It’s complicated, you know?”

The incident has sparked a wave of introspective X threads, with users dissecting the ethical quandary. “I had my blue-and-yellow filter ready to go,” posted @EquityEagle, a self-identified “anti-capitalist dreamweaver” from Austin. “But then I read the police report, and I was like, whoa, we need to unpack this systemic oppression angle before I commit to any hashtags.”

Academics have weighed in to provide clarity. Dr. Sage Thundercloud, a lecturer in Critical Transit Theory at Oberlin, published a 47-tweet thread arguing that the murder represents a “collision of hegemonies.” “On one hand, Ukraine is a victim of imperialist aggression,” Thundercloud wrote. “On the other, the unhoused community faces structural violence daily. We must hold space for both truths—unless it’s on public transit, then it’s just messy.”

In response, several activist collectives have organized “teach-ins” to debate whether supporting Ukraine constitutes “punching down” in light of the incident. A planned rally in Portland was rebranded as a “Vigil for Nuance,” with attendees handing out pamphlets titled “How to Stan a War Without Erasing Marginalized Narratives.” One organizer, clad in a thrifted Che Guevara beret, explained, “We’re not saying we don’t care about Iryna. We’re just saying her death needs to be contextualized within the broader carceral-industrial complex.”

Meanwhile, Ukrainian-American communities have expressed confusion over the pivot. “I thought ‘Slava Ukraine’ meant solidarity with our struggle,” said Olena Koval, a Chicago-based community organizer. “Now I’m being told it comes with an asterisk. I don’t even know what to say to that.”

On X, the new profile pic slogan has sparked some dissent among the faithful. “This is getting ridiculous,” tweeted @RadicalRealist, a rare voice of dissent. “Are we supporting Ukraine or not? Make up your minds.” The post was promptly ratioed by replies accusing the user of “erasing complexity” and “centering whiteness.”

As the debate rages, some activists have proposed a compromise: a rotating profile pic schedule, with “Slava Ukraine” displayed on even days and “Abolish Prisons” on odd days. Others have suggested tabling the Ukraine issue entirely until “more inclusive conflicts” emerge. For now, the left’s commitment to Ukraine hangs in the balance, contingent on the next viral nuance to derail the discourse.

In the meantime, Willow has already moved on, updating their bio to read: “Solidarity is a journey, not a destination. Also, DM for my SoundCloud.”

About Author