www.dailysignal.com
DC’s Hobson’s Choice Mayor
Hobson was an English horse dealer who famously gave customers only one horse to pick from, hence Hobson’s Choice. The expression sums up the mayoral contests in many American cities.
In Los Angeles, voters can choose between incumbent Karen Bass, whose “friend and mentor” was a Communist, or Nithya Raman, who “has been aligned with the Democratic Socialists of America” and is compared to fellow ethnic-Indian immigrant Zohran Mamdani, New York’s Mayor.
As Jeff Blehar from National Review explained, “California’s election system … is rotten to its core and has reduced California politics to a mere test of activist strength between warring factions of the Democratic Party—who can turn out more ballots from homebound, largely disengaged voters, the ultimate insider’s game.”
Sounds like Washington, D.C., where voters have just chosen Councilmember Janeese Lewis George as Democratic nominee for mayor in November. The District of Columbia Council of 13 has 11 Democrats and 2 supposed “independents.”
Given that 92% of registered District of Columbia voters are Democrats, that means George is our next mayor. So, what are we in for?
Pundits considered current mayor Muriel Bowser a moderate in her 12 years running the District of Columbia, but she was hardly that.
Bowser tolerated riots and mayhem in the name of BLM in 2020, because “[t]here is a lot of distrust of police and the government.” She pushed for the District of Columbia to become a state. And Bowser created the District of Columbia’s Office of Racial Equity, with the goal of “eliminating racial and ethnic equity gaps.”
This is a DEI-infused approach of blaming all disparities between ethnic groups in terms of crime, education, and wealth on racial discrimination, to the exclusion of all factors, and correcting it through preferential treatment.
Bowser blew a brief increase in tax revenue on a menu of social spending that led to a projected billion-dollar budget deficit in her last year. However, she avoided fiscal ruin by raising taxes and cutting programs.
Despite her electorate’s opposition to Donald Trump, Bowser also avoided direct confrontations that could have ended the city’s Home Rule, which dates back to the Nixon administration. And her administration reluctantly cleaned up a few parks that had been overrun with encamped vagrants since COVID-19. (I was hoping the one near me would reopen to taxpayers, but it has been fenced off, and its benches are now overgrown with grass … at least the rats have somewhere to play).
Don’t look for such restraint and realism from Lewis George, who “has promised an aggressive approach” to relations with Trump.
Lewis George is a member of the Democratic Socialists of America, like Mamdani and Rep Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y. Today’s Democratic Party is not the one Bill Clinton ran in the 1990s. On issues from crime and immigration to welfare, the party’s present positions have moved far to the left.
On abortion, many mainstream Democrats went from “safe, legal and rare” to no limits at all.
On immigration, they went from the bipartisan 1996 Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act to calling for the abolition of immigration enforcement—which means open borders and no deportations.
On welfare, they went from Clinton’s signature Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act, to calling critics of massive Medicaid fraud racists.
But if the Democrats have gone left, the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) are still much further to the left yet. As the City Journal explains, the DSA platform released in June commits them to “scrapping the U.S. Senate, ‘abolishing the carceral forces of the capitalist state,’ defunding the Department of War, amnesty for all immigrants, and ‘replac[ing] the President and Supreme Court with an executive and judiciary chosen by and subordinate to Congress.’”
Oh, and they want to name Jerusalem the capital of a Palestinian state, abolish the Electoral College, and nationalize private property.
Of course, individual DSA elected officials can differ with the national platform, but why call themselves DSA instead of Democrats unless they are with it in spirit?
Lewis George’s career so far shows her sympathies with the DSA agenda. She opposes a curfew to keep riotous teens at home and off Washington’s streets. During the campaign, she pledged not to attend “events focused on obfuscating the realities of occupation or promoting Zionism and apartheid.”
She wants Washington, D.C.—the seat of the federal government—to end all cooperation with Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the branch of the federal Department of Homeland Security that is tasked with enforcing immigration law.
Lewis George is a strong supporter of District of Columbia statehood. I wrote in 2024 the obvious five reasons why the federal District of Columbia should never be a state, starting with the Constitution and then the city’s failure to educate its children, or control corruption, crime, and vagrancy.
If, as expected, Lewis George becomes mayor, we can expect her to double down on socialist policies that have been proven to fail, time after time, in country after country. A fifth of the city is on food stamps. Forty percent are on Medicaid. They’ll always vote, if they vote at all, to keep the taps flowing.
Those of us who pay for it all are stuck with Hobson’s Choice of socialists.