www.dailywire.com
OnlyFans Model Gets Baptized At Church. Should We Believe Her?
The following is an adapted transcript excerpt from The Michael Knowles Show.
* * *
One of the OnlyFans models who slept with a thousand guys in one day, someone named Lily Phillips, has apparently just had a religious conversion.
I don’t know if that’s her real name or a stage name, but here is the question: Is Lily Phillips’s conversion sincere? And the broader question is how should Christians react to this?
Here’s the video of her baptism:
THIS! OF model Lily Phillips gets baptized after viral 1,000-men stunt, says she is now seeking faith and redemption.
I pray this is genuine. No one is ever too far gone for Jesus Christ. ?? pic.twitter.com/bmpvDvXXyx
— David J Harris Jr (@DavidJHarrisJr) January 2, 2026
Credit: @DavidJHarrisJr/X.com
There is a nice Kanye pop gospel song behind the video. She appears to be in either an Anglican or Episcopalian church and it’s a full immersion baptism in a bathtub. Her caption reads, “A day to remember forever.”
Now, some people are accusing her of being cynical. So why do I think she’s sincere? First of all, as you will see, she does not sound cynical to me. But even if she is, I always like to be on the side of credulity when it comes to these matters. Not to the point of absurdity, of course, but I always want to be on the side of grace when it comes to these things.
WATCH: The Michael Knowles Show
Well, turns out she recently did an interview with US Weekly where she explained her actions, saying:
I think for a while I’d kind of deviated from religion, and I think I was kind of in denial for a lot of it … Quite a big thing happened more in my personal life, where I kind of felt the need to start speaking to God again. I hadn’t really practiced faith for a while. I just wanted to get rebaptized to kind of reinstate my relationship with God.
So right off the bat, there is a major problem: you can’t get rebaptized. Baptism happens once. The Nicene Creed actually states this. All of the flavors of Christianity, even ones that are a little far flung from Orthodoxy, at the very least recognize the statement in the Creed that says, “I confess one baptism for the forgiveness of sins.” It’s one baptism, not two.
The reason you are only baptized once is that baptism is not a personal action of yours. Baptism is an action of God the Holy Spirit. It’s the grace of God coming down — and God doesn’t make mistakes. God doesn’t act insufficiently. It works. When God acts on you, when you are baptized, that leaves an indelible mark on your soul.
People do not have to be rebaptized. It’s like gay marriage — you can’t. Why? Because the sacrament works. But in our fallen, broken human life, we just feel like we need to do something more sometimes, and we get it wrong. But I get why people do it.
What she’s saying is, “I felt a calling to God,” and she reacted to that in a way that is silly at best and contrary to the religion at worst. But I think it comes from a good place, and I know other people who have done it.
She goes on:
I definitely need to do that because I think that there are a lot of Christian girls who are in this industry … but people might not know it and they might not feel comfortable talking about it because of the judgment.
I totally believe that. I totally believe that there are a lot of girls who are baptized Christians who feel a pull toward Christianity, toward God, who work in pornography and all sorts of disreputable fields. Whether we’re talking about prostitution or whether we’re talking about law and finance — I’m sure there are all sorts of people who feel a tension between the work that they do and religious truth. However, here’s where it gets a little dicey, and I think this is why some people are attacking Lily Phillips.
She says,
I’m definitely not claiming to be a traditional Christian at all. Obviously, I’m not against gay marriage. I am also pro-choice. So I definitely don’t have, necessarily, traditional values. But that doesn’t mean to say that I can’t be Christian. I would just hope that the Christian community welcomes me, because I guess everyone’s relationship with God is bespoke to them.
I think there are a lot of people who feel this way, at least in the early stages of their conversion. But we have to clear up a few things, so let’s break this down.
She says, “I’m not against gay marriage.”
Christianity does not permit so-called gay marriage. It is contrary to the Christian faith. The weird sex stuff broadly is contrary to the Christian faith. And even beyond questions of religious revelation, it just comes down to basic logic: two opposing things cannot be simultaneously true in the same respect, as per the law of non-contradiction. So, no, inasmuch as you believe these things of the world, you are opposing the Christian faith.
She says, “I am also pro-choice.”
The church, since the very beginning, has opposed abortion. You can see proscriptions against abortion in the UK, the very first catechism of the church, all the way back in antiquity, just after the Apostolic Age. You can’t do it. You can say that you’re Christian and you can say that you support killing babies, but those things are diametrically opposed. They’re totally in conflict with each other.
She then says, “So I definitely don’t have, necessarily, traditional values.”
What do we mean by “traditional values”? Are we talking about the traditions of China? No. Are we talking about the Chinese—some different values than we do here? Are we talking about the traditions of Islam, the caliphate? No. When we talk about traditional values in the English language, generally, we’re talking about the Christian tradition that built our civilization. So if you say, I’m Christian, but I don’t have Christian values, that’s confusing. She sounds confused by the twin darkness into which we are all born — ignorance and sin.
She says, “And I just hope the Christian community welcomes me.”
We will welcome you. I will welcome you, at least. But not on your terms. But we will welcome you. We’re not going to force you to do something that is maybe extremely difficult or impossible for you to do. We’re not expecting you to radically transform everything about your life all at once, but if you want us to welcome you, that means you have to come to the church, which means you have to give your assent to the church.
If two things are going to join together, one of them has to change. The thing that’s going to change is not going to be the church. It’s going to have to be you, which is true for all of us.
Every time we go into church, every time we go into confession, every time we go to receive the Blessed Sacrament, every time we go to mass, every time we go into a chapel to pray, we are imperfect — all of us. And when we go there, we are saying, “I want to be transformed by you, Lord.” I don’t want you and your holy institution to be transformed into myself.
She says, “I guess everyone’s relationship with God is bespoke to them.”
True, but God is the same for everyone. Everyone’s relationship with God is bespoke. It’s not off the rack. It’s not one size fits all. You’re right about that. But God is the same for everyone because God is objectively real. He’s the real God. That’s why you believe in him in the first place. And yet a lot of people want to make false gods for themselves.
She goes on to say, “I’m going to take more of a backseat in work and stuff like that, just to really prioritize this.”
Well, by work she means prostitution. She means pornography. She’s not going to give it up entirely yet, apparently. Too bad.
But she does say, “I’m going to prioritize religion.” Good, love that.
She then says,
Even though I travel so much, I don’t necessarily go to church a lot because I’m traveling, but it doesn’t mean I can’t pray and I can’t practice my religion outside of church. So I will definitely be doing that and taking that forward.
Well, you have an obligation to go to church on Sunday. You have an obligation to do that even if you’re not feeling it and don’t want to. You have an obligation to at least do that. You have other obligations too. But she’s right — you can pray outside of church, and you should. You have to live your faith all the other days of the week too. That’s true. However, when you don’t go to church, when you don’t practice your faith, when you sanction these kinds of awful things that are so harmful to people, you are making a choice to move away from God.
So, what should we do about the Lily Phillips conversion? Should we make her the Archbishop of Canterbury right away? Probably not. Should we put her on the podcast circuit? In this case, probably not just yet. This could take a little while.
Should we say you don’t have to change anything about yourself or what you believe to be a real, practicing Christian? No. She’s got to change, but I think we should encourage her.
This is my message to Lily Phillips: This is great news. Wonderful. I love it. I love hearing that this is happening for you. But you have got to keep going, young lady. You were in a very, very bad place and now, by God’s grace, you have apparently taken a step to get out.
It’s going to be a long journey, but God will be with you the whole way. So just keep going.