www.dailywire.com
The One Simple Trick That Could Lead Illegal Immigrants To Self-Deport
President Donald Trump and his administration have thrown out the playbook on immigration.
Between resurrecting an 18th-century law to deport violent criminals and running nationwide television commercials encouraging illegal immigrants to leave the country, the White House is employing anything and everything they can to remove illegals from the country, and strengthen the southern border. But experts say the Trump administration has another arrow in their quiver — one that’s not new, but still incredibly effective.
E-Verify is a free service from the Department of Homeland Security that allows employers to check applicants’ employment authorization status. Until now, proponents of E-Verify have encouraged employers to use the service to ensure they don’t hire illegals. But now, experts say mandating the service would spike the rate of self-deportations.
“There’s no question that a large part, and maybe most, of any reduction in the illegal population has to come through self deportation,” Center for Immigration Studies Executive Director Mark Krikorian told The Daily Wire. “A big share of any reduction in the illegal population will inevitably come — and has to come — through voluntary departure or semi-voluntary departure.”
A national E-Verify mandate, Krikorian says, is one of the ways that lawmakers could encourage illegal aliens to leave the United States.
“It would make it much more difficult to get work. It would mean that a significant number of people would…opt not to come here illegally or even decide to go home,” Krikorian said.
“What people don’t understand is that most illegal aliens work on the books, and E-Verify would make that much more difficult. You’d have to have much more sophisticated access to fake identities and fake stolen identities to be able to do that,” he added.
“There’s always churn in the illegal population, even under Biden illegal aliens were leaving. There’s always people coming and there’s always people going. The key is to increase the number of people going and decrease the number of people coming in,” he explained.
A recent study from the Federation for American Immigration Reform found that an estimated 18.6 million illegal aliens are present in the United States, with the figure eclipsing the individual populations of 46 of 50 states. Such a high number of illegal aliens poses serious logistical challenges to immigration enforcement authorities.
Ira Mehlman, the Media Director of the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR), told The Daily Wire that economic incentives are what pull so many illegal aliens to the United States, and that a change in those incentives could prompt their departure.
“The vast majority of illegal aliens — especially the ones who arrived during the Biden administration — are economic migrants. Their strongest motivation for coming here was the ability to find a job and better wages,” Mehlman told The Daily Wire before honing in on the E-Verify program in particular.
“If employers were mandated to use E-Verify and the government demonstrated the resolve to hold employers accountable, that would go a long way toward drying up the supply of jobs for illegal aliens, thereby eliminating the biggest incentive to come or remain here illegally,” Mehlman added.
“Faced with the reality that they are unlikely to find a job and the president’s executive order barring illegal aliens from nonessential benefits and services, many would make the logical decision to return home,” he asserted.
Several states have already implemented E-Verify mandates, giving lawmakers several examples to draw on for a federal requirement.
The Legal Arizona Workers Act, for example, requires all businesses to use the E-Verify program to check the status of all potential employees, and empowers county attorneys to bring civil suits against businesses that knowingly employ illegal aliens, potentially resulting in the suspension or revocation of their business licenses.
In Tennessee, companies with 35 or more employees are required to use E-Verify, and those with fewer employees must still verify the employment status of new hires either through E-Verify or by acquiring and retaining documents that show identity and work eligibility. Other Republican states, including Texas and Missouri, have implemented a limited form of E-Verify and require state agencies and certain government contractors to use the program.
Two Democrat-run states, California and Illinois, have taken the most radical actions against E-Verify, and bar city and county governments from mandating the use of the program.
Studies of E-Verify have found that the program is effective at curtailing illegal immigration and at protecting the economic interests of American workers who may otherwise be undercut by illegal labor.
“The results indicate that having an E-Verify law reduces the number of less-educated prime-age immigrants from Mexico and Central America — immigrants who are likely to be unauthorized — living in a state,” one study explains. “We find evidence that some new migrants are diverted to other states, but also suggestive evidence that some already-present migrants leave the country entirely.”
Another study found that E-Verify mandates improve the economic prospects of Americans who might otherwise be forced to compete with illegal aliens for employment.
“The mandates appear to lead to better labor market outcomes among workers likely to compete with unauthorized immigrants,” the abstract explains. “Employment rises among male Mexican immigrants who are naturalized citizens in states that adopt E-Verify mandates, and earnings rise among U.S.-born Hispanic men.”
Vice President JD Vance touted E-Verify during his time in the Senate, writing in 2022 that “E Verify might be the single most important immigration issue.” Vance also co-sponsored legislation that would have mandated the use of E-Verify for employers across the country.
Border Czar, Tom Homan has also praised the program, saying it “would save tens of millions of dollars annually in enforcement operations by making it much more difficult to use fake identities.”
“What’s frustrating to me … is that we even have some Republicans in Congress who don’t want to see E-Verify enacted,” Homan said in 2020. “If they truly want to stop illegal employment they need a system of checks and balances, and E-Verify, with some moderate changes, could be effective.”
Proponents of a national E-Verify mandate would have to face off against ideological organizations and corporate interests that undercut American workers with illegal labor, Mehlman noted.
“The entire panoply of organizations that advocate for illegal aliens certainly oppose mandatory E-Verify. So, too, do many cheap labor business interests for whom illegal immigration has become a source of subsidized labor. They pay low wages and everyone else picks up the costs of having the illegal aliens and their families in the country.”