reactormag.com
Holiday Spirits, A Killer Christmas, and R.L. Stine’s The New Evil
Books
Teen Horror Time Machine
Holiday Spirits, A Killer Christmas, and R.L. Stine’s The New Evil
It just isn’t Christmas until the Evil Entity is released from the ice.
By Alissa Burger
|
Published on December 18, 2025
Comment
0
Share New
Share
The Cheerleaders trilogy (1992) are among the most iconic books in R.L. Stine’s Fear Street series. We’ll check out the trilogy in the new year, but with the holiday season upon us, we’ll turn our attention first to Stine’s follow up Super Chiller to the trilogy, Cheerleaders: The New Evil (1994). Throughout the original trilogy, the Shadyside High School cheerleading squad found themselves up against an amorphous evil power that can take possession of humans and hide itself behind the faces of their closest friends, resulting in all manner of mayhem and murder.
When Stine returns to the cheerleaders in The New Evil, the evil seems to have been safely contained, frozen in ice in the nearby Cononoka River. But when mysterious “accidents” start taking out the cheerleaders one by one, Corky Corcoran begins to have her doubts. First, Hannah is badly injured when she, Kimmy, and Corky are in a car accident. The roads are slippery and Hannah’s not wearing her seatbelt when they crash, so jumping straight to a supernatural explanation might feel like a bit of a leap, though Kimmy is adamant that the evil is back. Corky tries to rationalize with her, telling Kimmy, “You can’t blame the evil spirit every time something bad happens … Sometimes bad things happen. They can’t be helped” (12). But Kimmy has planted a seed of doubt in Corky’s mind and she talks her boyfriend Alex into driving her out to the river to see for herself, where she finds an ice-fishing hole cut in the ice, with vapor rising from the water. This time, it’s Alex who tries to reason with Corky, explaining that the steam is rising from the hole in the ice “because the water below the ice is warmer than the air above the ice” (26), but Corky’s having none of it.
To be fair, accidents seem to plague the cheerleading squad, though there’s some doubt as to whether the evil spirit is to blame or just some cutthroat sabotage of the competition, as new girls vie to take Hannah’s spot on the team. At tryouts for Hannah’s replacement, team captains Corky and Kimmy narrow their choice down to three finalists: Ivy, Lauren, and Rochelle. Just when they’ve made their minds up to give the spot to Rochelle, she is badly injured when a workman loses his grip on a screwdriver, which plummets to the gym floor and lodges in the back of Rochelle’s neck. While this could just be a freak accident, a case of Rochelle being in the wrong place at the wrong time, this is complicated by Ivy’s eavesdropping on Kimmy and Corky’s deliberations and the workman’s anguished confusion, as he tells the cheerleading coach Ms. Closter “It flew out of my hand! … I don’t know what happened. I was holding it tight. But it just flew out!” (51, emphasis original).
Rochelle survives, but she won’t be cheering any time soon and as a result of her injury, Ivy makes the squad. Lauren is furious and lobbies the coach to be part of the team as an alternate, practicing with the cheerleaders and learning the routines, seemingly just biding her time until another unfortunate “accident” will free up a spot for her on the squad. Heather gets powder burns from a malfunctioning confetti cannon and Naomi is badly burned when a fire baton twirling routine goes wrong, and in no time, Lauren has her wish and takes her spot next to the other cheerleaders.
Corky, Kimmy, and Debra have confronted the evil before and they aren’t willing to take any chances, even if that means committing murder, which is where the lines between the influence of the evil and the actions the cheerleaders are willing to take to stop the evil begin to get a bit blurry. Debra has started dabbling in magic spells that can help them detect the evil, deciding it’s best to fight supernatural dangers with supernatural defenses. Corky, Kimmy, and Debra come up with a plan to invite their friends to a pre-Christmas skating party on the frozen river, cast one of these spells to find out who the evil is inhabiting—their top contenders are Ivy and Lauren—and then drown the girl in the icy river. This has worked before and they’re hopeful that once the girl is dead and the evil is forced to vacate her body, they can do some quick CPR to bring her back to life, but the possibility that Ivy or Lauren might actually die doesn’t seem to be a dealbreaker. All is fair in cheerleading and evil banishing, apparently. The spell seems to work and Ivy starts skating toward the three of them (though this could also reasonably be a natural, non-possessed “what the heck is going on over there?” response when she sees three of her fellow cheerleaders gathered around a circle of candles on the ice and chanting). It ultimately turns out that Corky, Kimmy, and Debra have had it wrong all along and when they cast the spell to draw the evil out, they release it from the ice, where it had still been trapped. All of the accidents were really just accidents (or sabotage) and in overzealously being on the lookout for the evil, they’ve brought it back, as it explodes from the frozen river in “A malodorous blanket of black fog … [that] darkened the ice, blackened the sky … The ice blistered and burned. The smoke spewed up thicker, faster, swirling up over the shivering trees, up to the clouds” (100-101).
And now the cheerleaders are in real trouble. The evil is definitely back, just in time for the basketball players and cheerleaders to travel to a pre-holiday tournament, with the evil of course coming along for the fun. One of the basketball players becomes uncharacteristically violent and belligerent with the coach, who is later discovered murdered near the locker rooms. The confetti cannon that the cheerleaders roll out again (despite their first disastrous attempt with it) spews hot black tar all over the fans, the seats, and the court, resulting in several serious injuries and the tournament being temporarily suspended, just when the Shadyside team was really getting into their groove. A cheerleader on the opposing team’s squad starts doing backflips and can’t stop. The Shadyside teens are far from home, unsupervised, and at the mercy of the evil spirit, but despite all of the terrifying things that are happening—including the violent and unsolved murder of one of their two chaperones—the tournament continues, with the Shadyside teens largely left to their own devices.
When Corky, Kimmy, and Debra follow the other cheerleaders and the basketball players to a nearby lake in the middle of the night, it feels like a reprise of their ill-advised skating party, but this time there’s definitely something weird going on, as the gathered teens form a circle, moving and dancing in unison with raised hands and blank eyes, as “Their shadows dipped and turned, dark blue against the gray ice. Slowly, the dancers moved, as silent as shadows” (151). They repel an angry dog with a collective supernatural strength, throwing the poor animal high into the air before he comes crashing back down to the ice, injured, frightened, and driven away. So this time, when the gathered group sets their sights on Corky, Kimmy, and Debra, there’s little doubt about the influence of the evil, which apparently possessed the bodies of ALL of their friends when that dark smoke rolled over them at the skating party. Prior to this, the evil has been content to claim one host at a time, but now the remaining cheerleaders are outnumbered and outmatched: the possessed teens drown Kimmy in the lake and Debra disappears when she and Corky get separated in the dark woods as they try to escape. When the sun comes up, Corky is alone but still alive, watching in horror as the possessed basketball players and cheerleaders climb onto the bus to head back to the tournament.
The evil spirit intends to kill the remaining cheerleaders and Corky decides the only way to stop it is to kill the evil first, which she attempts to do by hijacking the bus when the driver goes into the motel office and driving it off a cliff to plunge into the icy lake below. Corky bails out at the last moment, listening in mingled horror and triumph as all of her friends scream the whole way down to their frigid, watery graves. Like the skating party, she holds onto the naive hope that some of them might be resuscitated once the evil has been expelled from their dead bodies, but she’s fully aware that they could all die, and that’s a price she’s willing to pay. Traumatized and in shock, she walks to the arena to find her coach and tell her what has happened, but as Corky desperately tries to get Ms. Closter to see the truth, the Shadyside basketball players and what’s left of the cheerleading squad take the court, a rampaging horde of the angry and waterlogged undead, “lurching, stumbling after her, reaching for her with their swollen purple hands, coming for her, coming for their revenge” (187).
But not really. The final section of The New Evil is an uneasy combination of reality and Corky’s hallucinations, which are chalked up to a concussion. The basketball team and the other cheerleaders really were possessed by the evil. Kimmy really is dead. Corky really drove the bus off the cliff and walked to the arena in a daze. But the basketball players and cheerleaders never became the vengeful undead because they really were miraculously saved, pulled from the water and resuscitated by a couple of incredibly intrepid ice fishermen who just happened to be in the right place in the right time with the right skill set to make this incredibly difficult and dangerous rescue. The possessed teens have no memory of what happened while they were inhabited by the evil, including no memory of how they killed Kimmy or how Corky killed them, which presumably lets Corky off the hook for a whole slew of crimes.
The teens are themselves once more and grateful to be alive. One of the players heaves a big sigh of relief and exclaims “I still can’t believe everyone survived” (198) and just like that, Kimmy is forgotten, marginalized and nearly erased within the larger context of their shared trauma—or at least their shared trauma as they remember it, with only Corky and Debra aware of the whole dark story. As the teens recuperate in the hospital, they realize that it’s Christmas Eve. It seems like this year, their gift is their lives, though the horrifying reality of what actually happened is sure to be the gift that keeps on giving for the two girls … and if it’s anything like the Cheerleaders trilogy that came before The New Evil, there’s nothing to say the evil won’t come back for a visit in the new year.[end-mark]
The post Holiday Spirits, A Killer Christmas, and R.L. Stine’s <em>The New Evil</em> appeared first on Reactor.