reactormag.com
Down the Worst Roller-Coaster: Stephen King’s Pet Sematary (Part 20)
Books
Reading the Weird
Down the Worst Roller-Coaster: Stephen King’s Pet Sematary (Part 20)
The wendigo has done its work well, and no one is safe…
By Ruthanna Emrys, Anne M. Pillsworth
|
Published on March 26, 2025
Comment
0
Share New
Share
Welcome back to Reading the Weird, in which we get girl cooties all over weird fiction, cosmic horror, and Lovecraftiana—from its historical roots through its most recent branches. This week, we continue Stephen King’s Pet Sematary with Chapters 58-60. The novel was first published in 1983. Spoilers ahead! Ongoing content warning for dead kids and pets.
Jud’s slept through the night instead of watching for Louis. No, he didn’t fall asleep; he was put to sleep. He’s awakened by the sound of the porch door opening, then the front door. “Louis?” he calls, though he knows that whatever’s entered is “sent to punish an old man for his pride and vanity.” Footsteps approach, preceded by a “dirty, low smell—the smell of poisoned tidal flats.”
Two shadows enter the sitting room. “Gage?” Jud asks.
Church is the smaller shadow. Jud backs toward the kitchen, stumbling as Church twines around his ankles. He kicks the cat away. “It mayn’t be too late,” he thinks. “It’s back but it can be killed again.”
Jud pulls a cleaver from the utensil drawer. “It ain’t a kid,” he reminds himself. “It may cry. But you ain’t gonna be fooled yet again. This is your last chance.”
Church enters the kitchen first. Gage Creed follows, dressed in his moss-fouled burial suit. One eye is weirdly cocked. The other fixes on Jud.
Gage grins. His babyish voice is perfectly understandable: “Hello, Jud. I’ve come to send your rotten, stinking old soul straight to hell.”
Cleaver raised, Jud invites Gage to see who’s going to “fuck with who.”
Gage says he’s seen Norma burning in hell. She was “a cheap slut” who cheated on Jud with all his friends. The thing’s voice changes to Norma’s: She knew about Jud’s whores, but he never knew he married a whore or how she and his friends laughed about him together…
Jud springs toward Gage. Church trips him to the floor. He loses the cleaver. Gage attacks with Louis’s scalpel and drives its blade through the hand Jud raises.
And the scalpel slashes again. Again. Again.
* * *
A truck driver helps Rachel fix her rental. A battery cable came off, weird thing to happen to a new car. Yes, weird, Rachel thinks as she drives on, feeling she’s being manipulated. Held up just long enough for something irrevocable to happen.
By five o’clock, Jud’s dying. In Chicago, Ellie wakes from a nightmare, screaming. By quarter after, Rachel’s nearing Ludlow.
She goes first to the Crandalls’ house. The peaceful dawn would usually give her a lift, but today brings “a dragging sense of unease.” Louis’s car isn’t in their driveway. When Jud doesn’t answer his doorbell, Rachel notices muddy footprints on the porch floor: very small prints, a child’s. Church meows inside. She opens the door. He sits in the hallway, whiskers beaded with blood.
Crazily, memories of a monstrous Zelda interfere with Rachel’s rational fear that Jud’s hurt. Church meows upstairs now. Someone groans. Rachel runs to the second floor. Another groan, behind a closed door. Certain Zelda will be there, feeling like she’s shrinking to child-size, Rachel approaches.
The door’s snatched open, and Zelda’s there, back twisted, “smelling of piss and death.” Her illness has dwarfed her, so she can wear Gage’s burial suit, and her eyes are “alight with an insane glee.” She’s come back for Rachel, to twist her back and put her permanently to bed—
Then it’s Gage in front of Rachel, Church on his shoulder. His face is swollen, as if he’s been hurt and put back together by “crude, uncaring hands.” Rachel calls his name and stretches out her arms. Gage climbs into them and clings, one hand behind his back.
“I brought you something, Mommy!” he screams.
* * *
Louis wakes around nine. He’s stiff everywhere, but his banged-up knee’s the big problem. Only the hope that Gage is back gets him up. No Gage upstairs, but from a window Louis spots a strange blue Chevette in Jud’s driveway, with Church curled atop it.
Halfway downstairs, Louis remembers the Thing in the woods. His Disney World dreams merged with dreams about the Wendigo touching Louis to forever rot his good intentions. He’d become both a cannibal and the father of cannibals. He was in the Pet Sematary again, with the Batermans, and dead Jud with his dog Spot, Farmer Morgan with his bull, and—Rachel, dress splattered red.
Behind them, sky-tall, the Wendigo stood…
Stop, Louis tells himself. He’s going to make breakfast. After eating, he’ll shower, tend his injuries, and wait for Gage. The kitchen’s bright, but things feel awry, overshadowed. The phone rings. It’s Rachel’s father, asking if she got home all right. That’s when the sight of little muddy footprints freezes Louis’s heart. That blue Chevette, but where’s Rachel then?
Louis lies that Rachel’s home and fine. Irwin tells him Ellie had such a nightmare overnight she couldn’t stop sobbing. They had to take her to the hospital, where she was sedated. Louis asks if Ellie said what scared her. She talked about Oz the Gweat and Tewwible, Irwin replies. How Oz had killed her mother. Crazy thing, that’s how Zelda pronounced the Wizard’s name—did Rachel ever tell Ellie about Zelda? The doctor says Ellie had a delayed shock from Gage’s funeral. She should be all right, but won’t Rachel and Louis come back to Chicago? After Louis says they will, Irwin adds that Ellie said something else strange: “Paxcow says it’s too late.”
The call over, Louis sinks towards a swoon. Only the agony of landing on his swollen knee keeps him conscious. He fears Rachel’s dead. He knows he must wait for Gage, because wherever he might run, Gage would find him. What made him summon Gage back was grief, “the battery that burying ground survives on.” Its power feeds on Louis’s grief and sanity. He considers suicide, but first he must put things right.
Tracing Gage’s footprints, Louis discovers his scalpel missing. Luckily, his doctor’s bag contains other potent things…
As Louis prepares to act, he imagines a new family moving into this house, a young couple, no children yet but hopes and plans. They’ll congratulate themselves for getting the house cheap, not being superstitious about its recent past. And—
Perhaps they’ll have a dog…
What’s Cyclopean: Gage smells of “poisoned tidal flats.” When passing as Zelda, his face is “a raddled purple.”
The Degenerate Dutch: Why is Wendy so obsessed with accusing women of infidelity? Or is that just the best way to get at men with certain obsessions?
Madness Takes Its Toll: Madness takes a sizeable toll this week: Jud tries to hold onto his reason in the face of that horrible smell, “Zelda’s” eyes are “alight with an insane glee,” Ellie is “hysterical” in the older sense, Louis’s face is “out of a seventeenth-century painting of a lunatic asylum,” and he thinks that the wendigo has eaten his sanity.
Ruthanna’s Commentary
Sloooowwwww buildup—and now we’re on the downward slope of the roller-coaster, with no breaks. Gage and Church have teamed up, and no one is safe.
The wendigo has done its work well, and while blood and obscenity-spewing 6-year-olds are certainly disturbing, the worst thing to me is how every single player has gotten separated from their loved ones. Jud, Rachel, Louis, even Ellie, have all been pried off solo one by one, naps and car breakdowns carefully choreographed to make sure they face the horror alone. (Sorry, Irwin, you don’t count.) The wendigo knows their vulnerabilities: the illusions and insults and areas of confidence and doubt that will make for the absolute worst possible experience and worst possible death.
At this late date I can’t help but wonder about the monster’s motivation. If it wanted everyone dead, cat claws are in fact as good as a scalpel, and neither is as effective as a mind-controlled truck driver. But then, it’s a creature created by starvation and selfishness, so the point may in fact be cannibalism, metaphorical if not literal: children railing at adults with their worst fears in the worst possible language, expressions of love turned into routes for destruction, people dying in fear at the hands (if not will) of their loved ones. Getting killed by your toddler is much worse than getting killed by your cat.
But then, I wonder… is Louis right that if he doesn’t interfere, “Gage” and “Church” will go off on a continent-wide rampage? Or rather, is he right that they’d still do that if he isn’t there to suffer for it, to feel guilty about being a “father of cannibals”? Nobody wants to get flayed by a zombie six-year-old, but for most people it wouldn’t really be personal. Wendy is more interested in Louis’s suffering than his death, or he would’ve been first under the scalpel.
He is absolutely right that Ellie is still in Chicago, and that would be personal. And presumably Wendy would want to entertain itself on the way.
Poor Ellie. Being a powerful little girl in a King novel is never good, and clairvoyance is not one of the fun powers to begin with. So she’s ended up in the hospital, sedated for “hysteria.” On the one hand, no one needs to be conscious and processing omens while her family is being murdered by her undead brother. On the other hand… on the other hand, sedation has been the consistent strategy for dealing with overset women and girls throughout this book, and that reflects something. Male emotion must be suppressed or translated into action, but female emotion is simply too intense for survival. Never mind that it’s Louis’s emotions that have proven deadly. I fear for Ellie’s future, and not just because of said undead brother. Under the best of circumstances, what are the odds that Irwin and Dory are up for keeping another mad girl at home, twenty years later? What will they do, for her own good?
But maybe I’m wrong. Maybe she’ll recover, at least enough to convince everyone that she’s articulate and rational and safe. And then she can set out on her own, beset by visions, looking for Charlie and Carrie to help her learn how to bear her burden.
Anne’s Commentary
If it had only happened another way. If she or he or they had only, if we had only, if you had only. Most heartbreaking, if I had only. One act of courage or honesty, one modicum of restraint, one moment sooner or later, one tiny whim, and things could have been different in a way that would have made all the difference. Someone who claims they never wanted to change something in their past is trying to avoid talking or thinking about that something. Fair enough. Lady Macbeth, practical even in her madness, mutters that “what’s done cannot be undone.”
Jud Crandall, stolid Yankee fatalist when he’s done things too wild to accept the blame for, says, “The soil of a man’s heart is stonier… A man grows what he can… and he tends it.” Intermittently, he knows this pithy credo is a cop-out. He admits to Rachel that “I better be able to take care of what’s happening [to Louis in her absence] because what’s happening is my fault.”
Ain’t free will a bitch?
But ain’t predestination a bitch as well?
The Puritans tied themselves into knots trying to build a moral society around the idea that you’re either saved or you’re not—good actions can’t redeem you if you’re predestined for Hell, and vice versa. One solution: If you’re innately good, you’ll naturally prove it via your virtuous acts; innately bad, you’ll naturally prove it via your vicious ones.
With this sort of theology in your cultural background, peace of mind may depend on labeling your “bad” actions as well-intentioned, springing from innate goodness, hence not really “bad.” Why does Jud take Louis to the Micmac burial ground? Oh, he knows Ellie will be bereft without her cat. Ergo, it’s only kind to restore the cat, pretty much intact. Never mind the consequences of Wendigo-powered resurrection. Suppress the notion that by sharing the Big Secret, you’re entangling another person in Its alluring webs.
Its greatest allurement is this: What’s done can be undone. Including the ultimate if-only: If only my loved ones didn’t have to die.
Some say they don’t reread books because they already know how the story ends. Such foreknowledge doesn’t matter to rereaders because they read for more than what happens in the final pages. They reread to enjoy the prose itself, the plot flow, the characters who feel like old friends or pet enemies. I experience another rereading phenomenon in many of my literary “second helpings.” Call it a suspension of foreknowledge, a sense that the characters’ fates are not finalized by the publication process, ink on paper, pixels on screens. Somehow, on a second or hundredth reading, things might happen differently.
Pet Sematary is a reread novel in which I tenaciously cling to the hope things will change. I want so badly for the Creeds to live long and happy lives. King himself wanted it so badly that in Chapter 40 he wrote a whole alternate future for Gage. The immediate plot difference that makes all the difference is that instead of Louis’s fingers sliding off Gage’s jacket, they snag it, halting his son on the brink of the road. The chain of possible earlier saves is long: If only Gage tripped before reaching the road; if only Gage obeyed his parents and stopped running; if only Gage hadn’t gotten the urge to play catch-me; if only the Creeds had put up a fence to keep the kids safe from the dangerous road; if only that particular truck hadn’t come along; if only the truck-heavy road didn’t run by the Creeds’ property; if only the Creeds hadn’t come to Ludlow, where a malicious presence lurked in the woods hungry for death and grief and desperation. The chain could branch into the if-onlies involving Jud and others, all the way back to whoever made the Wendigo-assuaging burial ground to begin with.
I know none of these if-onlies will happen. Yet I hope, and so viscerally re-experience the Creeds’ macabre tragedy. Am I looking for catharsis, a ritual cleansing through vicarious emotional release, that theoretical motor behind art in general, the weird and horrible in particular?
To stretch the metaphor: If-onlies are the fuel of that emotion-motor, or at least a powerful fuel additive. What could-have-been makes what-actually-is all the more poignant, or in the case of Pet Sematary, all the more crushing.
A parting conundrum: That the force behind Pascow’s apparition sees the future argues for predestination. That Pascow bothers to warn Louis argues that the future’s not preset. Through free will, Louis might alter his possible (even probable) destiny.
Here’s a “fun” essay question. Extra points for including a concise yet comprehensive analysis of the Puritan/Calvinistic “shadow over New England weird fiction.” Negative points for those of you who just head-planted on your exam booklet…
Next week, we revisit the town from “The Night Wire” with Stephen Graham Jones’s “Xebico.”[end-mark]
The post Down the Worst Roller-Coaster: Stephen King’s <i>Pet Sematary</i> (Part 20) appeared first on Reactor.