reactormag.com
Give Me an E-V-I-L! — R.L. Stine’s Cheerleaders Trilogy
Books
Teen Horror Time Machine
Give Me an E-V-I-L! — R.L. Stine’s Cheerleaders Trilogy
Always make sure your evil spirit can be drowned BEFORE you try to dispose of it in a river.
By Alissa Burger
|
Published on January 8, 2026
Comment
0
Share New
Share
There’s never a dull moment on Fear Street, from murderous teens to supernatural dangers like ghosts and werewolves. But for many ‘90s teen horror readers, few of these dangers loom as large in our memories as the evil spirit that terrorizes the Shadyside High cheerleading squad in R.L. Stine’s 1992 Cheerleaders trilogy, with The First Evil published in August, The Second Evil in September, and The Third Evil in October, just in time for some Halloween hijinks. Stine’s Cheerleaders trilogy combines a supernatural threat with mean girl sabotage, while simultaneously drawing the cheerleaders (and Stine’s readers) into Fear Street’s dark history with the legacy of Sarah Fear.
The First Evil begins as so many Fear Street books do: with a family new in town, moving into a house on Fear Street, and no idea what they’ve gotten themselves into. This time, it’s the Corcoran family, including teenage girls Bobbi and Corky, their pesky younger brother Sean, and their parents. Bobbi and Corky are superstar cheerleaders. and they’re hoping if they can make the Shadyside squad they’ll be able to make friends, climb the social ladder, and keep competing in the sport they love. Head cheerleader Jennifer Daly is welcoming and enthusiastic, gushing to her friend and fellow cheerleader Kimmy Bass that “They were all-state back in their old hometown … And you know that cheerleading competition that’s on ESPN every year? … Well, their cheerleading team won it last year. That’s how good the Corcorans are” (13). Bobbi and Corky have a lot to bring to the table and to the team, but the squad roster was set in the spring and the girls have been practicing together all summer. Couple that with the fact that spots on the team are limited—meaning that if the Corcorans make the squad, another cheerleader will lose her place—and it’s not surprising that the rest of the girls aren’t so sure about welcoming Bobbi and Corky with open arms, or even giving them the chance to try out. But Jennifer insists, the Corcoran sisters’ routine is undeniably impressive, and Bobbi and Corky are on the team … which means somebody else has to go. As the coach Miss Green explains to Jennifer, “The squad is supposed to be six … I suppose we can squeeze one more girl on. But not two. We don’t have the funds for eight cheerleaders” (21), and freshman Ronnie Mitchell is the odd girl out.
Chemistry on the squad is complicated, with Kimmy and her friend Debra Kern particularly resistant to welcoming Bobbi and Corky onto the team. On the way to the first football game of the season, the cheerleaders’ bus needs to make a detour to Fear Street to pick up Bobbi and Corky’s fire batons, which they took home to practice and forgot there. As is usually the case, a quick trip to Fear Street ends badly, with the bus skidding and overturning on the wet road. Jennifer is thrown clear of the crash… coming to rest at the base of Sarah Fear’s tombstone in the Fear Street cemetery. She’s not breathing, and even the paramedics can’t revive her, but as Bobbi and Corky look down at their friend’s body before she is taken away “Jennifer opened her eyes … Her lips trembled. Her dark eyes moved from side to side … Jennifer smiled up at them both” (42). Tragedy seems to be averted and though Jennifer’s injuries are serious, they’re all grateful it wasn’t worse, and the girls try to get back to some semblance of their usual routine.
Jennifer has to use a wheelchair as she recovers but she enthusiastically takes on the role of a cheerleader for the cheerleaders, providing moral support even though she can’t take up the pom poms herself. And the cheerleaders need lots of moral support, because everything starts going wrong: first, Miss Green names Bobbi the new captain instead of Kimmy, and the others register their displeasure through refusing to follow Bobbi’s instructions, resisting her leadership, and continuing to treat Bobbi and Corky as unwelcome outsiders who don’t belong. Kimmy gets even more upset when her ex-boyfriend Chip asks Bobbi out, which sows further dissent among the cheerleaders. Then one afternoon as the team is practicing a stunt, Bobbi is in position to catch Kimmy as she dismounts from the top of the pyramid, but Bobbi discovers that she is frozen in place, unable to lift her arms or cry out a warning: “She could see herself standing there, as if she had floated out of her own body … She could see herself looking up as Kimmy prepared to dive, looking up at her with her arms still at her sides … Unable to move them, to raise them … Unable to catch Kimmy” (101). Kimmy hits the ground hard. No one believes Bobbi’s explanation about being frozen in place and the other girls are elated when Bobbi is kicked off the squad, Kimmy is named captain, and everything is at least a step closer to being back to “normal.”
But there’s nothing “normal” about Bobbi’s post-practice shower, when the doors slam shut, the water from the shower heads begins to boil, and there’s no escape. When Corky finds her sister’s body in the showers, “Bobbi stared back at her with vacant, wide-eyed terror, her flesh swollen and red, her mouth locked open in a silent scream” (133). And “normal” slips even further away when Corky goes looking for Jennifer, only to find her dancing on Sarah Fear’s grave, with the startling confession that she’s not Jennifer at all. Sarah Fear was inhabited by an evil spirit and when she died, the spirit was trapped in the grave with her; when Jennifer’s body conveniently landed on Sarah Fear’s grave during the bus accident, the evil spirit found a new host, taking up residence in Jennifer’s body, concealing the fact that Jennifer has actually been dead since the accident. The evil spirit tries to entomb Corky in Sarah Fear’s grave, but the other cheerleaders show up and see undeniable proof of the supernatural threat that has been tormenting them all. When Corky prevails, the evil spirit is forced back into Sarah Fear’s coffin and Jennifer’s body deteriorates in one fell swoop, as her “skin dried and crumpled, flaking off in chunks. Her long hair fell off, strands blowing away in the breeze. Her eyes sank back into her skull, then rotted into dark pits” (164). This is gruesomely horrifying and they mourn Jennifer’s loss, but they also heave a big sigh of relief, believing that they have found, bested, and contained the evil.
But of course, that’s not the case. In The Second Evil, Kimmy, Debra, and the others are a lot kinder to Corky, trying to convince her to rejoin the cheerleading squad, which she quit after her sister Bobbi’s death and the horrors of the evil spirit. But as Corky’s thoughts turn back to cheerleading, danger looms once more. While boiling the kettle for cocoa, Corky finds her body falling under someone else’s control, unable to move her hand as she pours the boiling water over herself. Corky’s not sure who she can trust and she has a range of experiences that could be the result of post-traumatic stress or the influence of the evil spirit, such as when she tries to join the others in a cheer and is overcome with the sounds of a woman screaming and visual hallucinations as the gym begins to spin around her. Kimmy encourages Corky to lean on her fellow cheerleaders, telling her “If we’re going to find the evil, if we’re going to fight it, we have to work together. If you’re not on the squad, you’re not really with us. You’re alone” (102). This seems like an amplified version of the insularity and cliquish behavior that caused so much trouble in The First Evil, but Kimmy has a point: who else is going to believe Corky? Her fellow cheerleaders are all she has, but she has no idea whether or not she can trust them, suspecting that one of them may be the new host for the ancient evil.
The scope of the evil widens beyond the cheerleaders in The Second Evil. Corky is chased down the school hallway by a mysterious stranger, but at least he turns out to be a flesh and blood human: Jon Daly, the very angry brother of Jennifer, who doesn’t believe a word of what the cheerleaders have had to say about his sister’s death. While Jon doesn’t believe in the evil, Corky meets someone who does when she sees a young woman at Sarah Fear’s grave. The girl introduces herself as Sarah Beth Plummer, a local college student with an interest in history, who just happens to be in the Fear Street cemetery doing gravestone rubbings, though the truth (as the cheerleaders eventually discover) is deeper and more complicated than that. Sarah Beth is a descendent of the Fear family, and while she habitually uses her mother’s maiden name (and who could blame her?), her legal name is Sarah Fear, and this Sarah Fear has been digging into her ancestor’s complicated history and tragic death.
Sarah Beth is keeping secrets, Jon is angry, and one of the cheerleaders is likely being controlled by the evil spirit, which leaves Corky with nowhere to go and no one she can turn to. There is a redux of Kimmy’s accident from The First Evil, this time with Kimmy frozen in place when Corky jumps from the top of the pyramid, breaking her arm. When Corky gets home from the hospital and is ready to sink into a nice, hot bath, Kimmy is waiting for her in the bathroom, driven by the ancient evil and ready to finish the job. Corky overpowers Kimmy, holds her head under the water, and watches as the evil spirit leaves Kimmy’s body in a noxious ribbon of green goo, until “As it oozed down the drain, the thick green liquid made a disgusting sucking sound that grew louder and louder, echoing in Corky’s head, vibrating, vibrating until the walls appeared to shake” (163). When Kimmy comes back to her senses, she is wet, nearly drowned, and doesn’t have a single memory of anything that happened since the night the cheerleaders faced off against the evil at Sarah Fear’s grave the first time, revealing its clever bait and switch in which the evil spirit tricked Corky into believing it had been drawn back into Sarah Fear’s coffin, while taking up residence in Kimmy’s body. This time, the suspense about whether or not the evil has been defeated is short-lived, with Corky finding an anonymous note in the mail the next day, telling her that “IT CAN’T BE DROWNED” (167).
It doesn’t seem like the horror will ever end for the cheerleaders and in The Third Evil, not only are they vigilantly keeping watch for the evil, they also have a new cheerleader to contend with, a perky, know-it-all freshman named Hannah Miles. In The First Evil, Corky couldn’t figure out why the other cheerleaders were so resistant to her and Bobbi trying to show them how it’s done but now, the shoe is on the other foot. Corky’s used to being the best and Hannah gets on her nerves, as she thinks “We all know Hannah is good. Why does she have to show off all the time? … Then she had to admit to herself: I guess I’m a little jealous” (5). The team dynamics are as complicated as ever, with Hannah trying to cement her spot on the squad through over the top enthusiasm and unsolicited advice, and when Debra defends Hannah, Corky feels betrayed. The team goes to a week-long cheerleading camp at a nearby college and between the competition with the other squads and the disagreements between themselves, tensions are running high. And that’s all before the evil strikes again, with Corky having a horrifying vision of the floor melting to pull her down and someone cutting off Hannah’s long braid while she sleeps. Hannah is sharing a room with Corky and Kimmy, and Corky’s first suspicion is that the evil spirit has taken control of Kimmy’s body again.
But this time, Corky’s the one they all need to fear. The Cheerleaders trilogy is aligned with Corky’s point of view, which means that Corky’s possession in The Third Evil gives readers a closer look at the evil and its influence than in the previous two books. Corky feels herself being engulfed in a pool of blood, “Drowning in it. Drowning in the thick dark blood … thrashing her arms and legs … kicking frantically … trying to swim … but feeling herself pulled down, sucked down into the bubbling, dark ooze” (89). Corky cannot escape the evil inside her, which steps to the forefront and takes control of her body, using it to do things she would never otherwise do. When she is playing with her little brother, the evil nearly breaks his arms, and it forces Corky to call Debra, arrange a meeting, and then try to kill her. This interiority gives the reader a glimpse of subjective experience of the evil’s possession, including Corky’s valiant struggle to resist it and her ultimate powerlessness in the face of its strength. In The First Evil, Jennifer was dead while she was inhabited by the evil, and in The Second Evil, the spirit took over Kimmy so completely that she has no memories of what happened in the intervening months. There’s no explanation for why Corky’s experience of the evil is different, but this time, rather than being on the outside looking in, trying to figure out where the evil might be lurking, there’s no mystery on that front.The horror is instead grounded in Corky’s internal struggle, one which is invisible to those around her.
The evil’s presence within Corky’s mind and body also give her unparalleled access, which ultimately leads her to the answers she needs, courtesy of Sarah Fear. When Corky has a vision of being Sarah Fear in the moments before Sarah’s death, she realizes that the evil spirit “took over their minds. It possessed their minds. And that meant that it also possessed their memories … So somewhere deep within the mind of the ancient evil spirit, somewhere deep inside that sleeping evil, Sarah Fear’s memory remained” (118, emphasis original). When Corky taps into the memories of the last day of Sarah Fear’s life, she makes a horrifying discovery: the only way Sarah Fear was able to trap the evil was by dying with it inside her body and no way to get out, by drowning herself in Fear Lake. Corky struggles with this solution but finally decides that it’s the only way, driven by her love for and desire to protect her friends and family, just as Sarah Fear decided she would let the evil go no further when it threatened to jump into the bodies of her young niece and nephew. Corky and the evil have cross purposes when they head to the cliff overlooking the Cononoka River to meet Kimmy, with the evil bent on killing Kimmy and Corky determined to end her own life, taking the evil spirit with her. At first glance, they both seem to get what they want: Corky pushes Kimmy over the side of the cliff before she jumps herself, but Kimmy isn’t killed in the fall and she is able to pull Corky’s dead body from the river and revive her, sans evil spirit.
In the final page of The Third Evil, it’s not entirely clear what the cheerleaders think happened to the evil spirit. They might be hoping the spirit died when Corky’s body died, though given the fact that it survived just fine in the coffin with Sarah Fear’s corpse for almost a hundred years, this doesn’t seem likely. Corky is certain that the evil is no longer inside her, which just leaves the river, and since it can’t be drowned, this is presumably only a temporary fix, though with the swiftness of the current, maybe it will become the problem of someone downriver. But this is Shadyside and Fear Street, so odds are that it will just keep hanging around, waiting for the opportunity to claim another victim and make its horrifying return (which is exactly what happens in the 1994 Super Chiller Cheerleaders: The New Evil). On Fear Street, the more things change, the more they stay the same: Sarah Fear sacrificed herself to contain the evil spirit, but nearly a century later, its influence is as powerful, terrifying, and inescapable than ever. Abandon all hope, ye who enter Fear Street or join the cheerleading team.[end-mark]
The post Give Me an E-V-I-L! — R.L. Stine’s <em>Cheerleaders</em> Trilogy appeared first on Reactor.