reactormag.com
Lanterns Turns Toward a Mystery in “Bad Optics”
Movies & TV
Lanterns
Lanterns Turns Toward a Mystery in “Bad Optics”
And now we’ve got ourselves a murder to solve…
By Emmet Asher-Perrin
|
Published on September 21, 2026
Image: John Johnson/HBO Max
Comment
0
Share New
Share
Image: John Johnson/HBO Max
Well I’ve gotta brand new status quo for you, you’ve got a brand new ring…
Recap
Image: John Johnson/HBO Max
It’s 2026 and John Stewart’s life looks a whole lot different. He’s become an architect, and now works with brother Marcus (Jared Grimes) to build panic rooms. After the events in Metropolis—namely the events of Superman—John and his brother are seeking out government contracts to use money that would normally be spent on weapons in order to scale the concept up into shelters for Midway City. The city council is on board, but John needs to convince the military to get the money, which he’s confident he can do. He gets a call from his mother, who he now refers to solely as Bernadette; they clearly do not speak often, and she wants John to reconnect with Hal Jordan, who is newly released from prison after the Rushville incident.
Apparently, Bernadette has been talking to Hal regularly during his stay, saying that he was lonely and needed someone to confide in. She believes he’s grown and tells John that he wants to apologize, asking him to go see the man in Rushville. John heads to the cafe there to meet Hal, who is totally uninterested in apologizing, in fact. He insists that they’re both to blame to what happened, and that he took that fall for it—John is also a killer, and Hal thinks he’s angry at his mother because she’s unbothered by that. John gets angry enough to clock Hal, breaking his nose and stalking out. Before he gets to the door, Hal warns him not to tell anyone that he was there.
The next call John gets is from Sheriff Kane: Hal is dead. They find him frozen in the football field bleachers and his (depowered) ring is nowhere to be found. Kerry tells John that Hal started writing her from prison once her relationship with Billy imploded, then moved to the town on his release and tried to make amends with the people still living there, asking to mow lawns, run errands, and the like. Everyone hated him and refused to give him the time of day. Kerry gives John the keys to the place Hal was renting—there’s no more motel as no one rebuilt—and John finds Earl there in a tray next to Hal’s bed. (He also finds a shotgun setup to shot anyone who comes through the front door.) He gets a call from Marcus, who wants to know if they’re still on for their meeting with the colonel, and John assures him that they are. Earl hears of Hal’s demise and looks visibly depressed.
John and Kerry have coffee at the cafe the next morning and the woman who was working there the night that Hal died doesn’t reveal that she saw John there, or that he punched Hal in the face. The coroner agrees to delay the announcement of Hal’s death as a favor to Kerry, hating both Hal and John, stating that his death was a cut and dry shot to the head and assuming that the person who broke is nose did it. There’s no sign that Hal fought back. Amongst Hal’s possessions, there’s a key to a storage unit, and when they investigate, they find large cube that requires Hal’s voice print to unlock. They try to use a recording from Kerry’s phone, but it doesn’t work, and the cube informs them that they have received their only warning and must use a live voice next time. As they leave the storage facility, John insists to Kerry that Hal get a proper burial, which she agrees to after telling John to come have dinner with her and Noah.
Image: John Johnson/HBO Max
There’s a signal in the center of Rushville just like the Batman one—the new Green Lantern, Guy Gardner (Nathan Fillion), had it installed as a sort of mea culpa for the incident. John turns it on, which the townspeople take exception to, including Billy. John beats up the entire group when they attack and flees, heading to Kerry’s for dinner. He enjoys talking to Noah (Shea Pritchard), who apparently has big ambitions, wanting to be a senator and maybe even president one day. Kerry gets the call about John beating up the townspeople and sends Noah to his room, then puts John in jail, claiming that she’s keeping him safe from everyone. John calls Marcus for bail money, and the next morning, Guy Gardner is sitting outside his cell.
Guy insists that he can’t help with the case because it’s bad optics, but that’s not why John called: He wants Hal buried in his uniform and ring. Guy points out that’s a military convention, but John says Hal was the first Earth lantern and has earned it. Hal’s ring was decommissioned—Guy has a brand new one, which means the old ring is locked up on Oa and Guy would have to break in and retrieve it. John suggests Guy is scared to get in trouble and, when that doesn’t work, reminds Guy that he’s owed: The only reason he’s got this job is because John passed on it. Guy lets him know that Sinestro broke out of the Guardians’ prison, and Hal would have been the prime suspect on that were he not dead.
John’s bail is posted and he immediately has to call Aaron for help with their father, who is getting kicked out of his senior living facility for brandishing a gun and shooting out his window. Aaron believes that John still owes him and isn’t interested in helping, but John reminds his brother that he’s bankrolled his entire music career and has done his part to make amends in their relationship, commanding him to pick up their father now. When he arrives back at Hal’s rented place, the server Maggie (Hannah Christine Shetler) from the cafe is there, and she wants “reparations” for her silence and the trauma she suffered when Rushville was decimated. A very specific number that she believes Hal and John cost her. He has until tomorrow to pay up or she tells the sheriff what she saw.
Image: John Johnson/HBO Max
Noah shows up at John’s door with a suit for him to wear to the funeral. Everyone local is asking the kid where he’s going to college, and John reminds him to care only about the bar he sets for himself, admitting that he has trouble doing that himself and hopes to steer the kid better than he was. Noah isn’t coming to the service given his mom not talking to him about her relationship wth Hal and his dad hates the guy. At the church, Guy is present and Hal is in his uniform and ring. He insists that they’re square now and leaves. John gets a call from Marcus and lets him know that he’s not back, but that he can do their meeting over the phone. John meets Hal’s old partner Carol Ferris (Amie Mackenzie), who is at the funeral because Kerry got in touch. She gives John a eulogy to deliver, one that Hal wrote for himself because she doesn’t think she can pull it off. She notes that Hal probably liked John a lot and never said so.
John delivers the eulogy, which starts out sort of silly and ends very somber. He tells Kerry that he’s thinking of sticking around for a few days to tie up loose ends. That night, John starts digging up Hal’s grave and gets the call from Marcus, who puts on the colonel. The call seems to drop, only for John to learn that the colonel actually hung up on him and walked out. He promises that he’ll fix it, but Marcus points out that John has been stuck in Rushville since what happened there ten years ago. He hopes it doesn’t kill his brother. Once the grave is exhumed, John takes Hal’s ring and calls up the hologram version of him. He looks into the grave, sees his own dead body, and curses.
Commentary
Image: John Johnson/HBO Max
Time jumps that establish a new status quo are always fun, especially when they manage to pack in believable changes that you don’t see coming. There were several in here that I found enjoyable, starting with Bernadette becoming Hal Jordan’s weekly prison call??
So when you said “don’t tell me you fell for that man,” and mentioned to John how charming he was, you had already fallen for that, huh Bernadette. And you hid the regular correspondence for a decade. I get that John isn’t exactly talking to you enough to notice it, but you are literally penpals with the guy on the down low.
More to the point, I have to assume that she started that correspondence because why would Hal do it? There’s no indication that he was reaching out to John in all that time, but we can see that the fallout between John and his parents was nuclear. Mom now gets referred to by her first name and dad is on a fast deterioration slope. The specifics aren’t given, but there are a lot of potential possibilities here for Bernadette in this choice, and I’m guessing a little bit of all of them created the situation: Her disappointment with John not following through on his destiny; her upset at John Sr. for not being “strong enough” to get the ring possibly translating into an irrational belief that he wasn’t “strong enough” to resist his own mental decline; Hal being the person who was strong enough and also the last person who had a connection to John before she lost him; Hal being far more willing to deal in moral grayness than John ever was.
On the other side, we’ve got John, who has broken some patterns, but certainly not all of them. You can’t blame him for shattering the ties with his parents after what happened in Rushville, particularly if what Hal suggested about Bernadette’s reaction was true—namely that she didn’t see the problem with John having to kill Zoe in order to end the conflict and get the ring, despite the fact that it utterly broke his heart. The two of them calling while John was in the middle of that fight and having absolutely no care for his personal well being couldn’t have helped either.
There’s a very specific dynamic that played out there, namely the kind where a child who has worked so hard all their life to be what their family requires of them finally hits the most important realization of all: That their accomplishments will never be enough to secure the love and support and safety they are owed. This show is all about what we owe to the people in our lives, in fact—in this episode alone, more than one character is talking about what they owed and from whom and why. There’s a constant scale in need of balancing, and John only has a decade of experience in his life finally demanding what he’s owed from others.
It’s hard for him, as we can see. He struggles with what he owes to his parents, not cutting them off completely, but limiting his contact to looking after their base needs. He is finally at a breaking point with eldest brother Aaron, who clearly took John’s guilt and milked that for all it was worth, and now needs to pull some of his own weight again. John says that his choice not to take the ring led to a reconnection with his family at the start of the episode, but what he really means is a reconnection with Marcus. That is the only relationship in John’s family that seems to run in both directions, with Marcus actively and honestly worrying for John and asking about how he’s really doing. When Marcus tells John that he hopes this tying up of loose ends doesn’t kill him, it’s clear that he means it, not just for the business but because he’s worried.
Marcus, at present, is the only person who tells John that he loves him and the only person John returns that sentiment to with warmth rather than obligation. That relationship is his lifeline, ostensibly the only thing keeping him afloat.
Because despite how well John has bounced back from his entire upbringing and first decade plus of adulthood being a sham, the shape of this new life is… telling. John is an architect, but what he builds are panic rooms: places for rich people to hold out against home invasion and anything else that scares them. And he clearly gets a certain measure of satisfaction from that act due to his trauma from Rushville—he keeps repeating that he helps people feel safe. A goal that he always had, arguably, but one that he thought he’d be fulfilling differently. Now he and his brother are asking to build state of the art emergency shelters for Midway City, a desire to scale up and help more people using government funds, but it doesn’t seem like John’s heart is in it. It’s hard to be someone who wants to do tangible good, but can only make it happen by kowtowing to the proper authorities.
Outside of this, we’re given no indication that John has been doing anything else in his life—no friends, no partner, no children, no outward community. He resides in a Hannibal-esque house that he likely designed himself, and it’s beautifully appointed while looking barely lived in. It is, in effect, his own version of Hal’s empty mansion. Better made, sure, suited to his tastes, absolutely. But in the end, it’s just another empty house.
Image: John Johnson/HBO Max
Then we’ve got Hal, who got out of jail and promptly tried to make amends in a town where no one was interested, but the attempts sounded spectacularly humble. Hearing about it from Kerry visibly affects John, the same way that hearing from Carol that Hal probably liked him seems to momentarily lift 35 years of trauma from his face. Hal and John are too similar, again—they both yearn for praise from people who are unwilling to give it. This is why that meeting in the cafe goes wrong; though he told Bernadette he meant to apologize, it’s clear that Hal wanted John to come back so they could settle whatever is happening in Rushville. Any apology he might have considered (if he considered it at all) was coming later, after the work. It’s always after the work. That’s why it’s too late.
The key to this discrepancy is how Hal treats John like a partner when John wants nurturing and care from him. Don’t get me wrong, Hal’s also an asshole, and very purposefully so… but as Carol said, he likes John. And he treats him as a contemporary in that meeting at the cafe: why should I apologize, we both know what happened and we’ve still got work to do, let’s move on. But John is less healed than he’s trying to be. He wanted candor and got the bravado end of the stick, and he was rightly tired of it. Hal only gets the chance to warn him about hiding his return.
It’s still sort of absurd to me narratively that not a single person holds Zoe accountable for what happened? While it’s easier to direct blame and anger onto living parties, I just find it hard to believe that not a single person in that town would argue the point. Groups of people generally don’t believe things unilaterally all together, even in the wake of horrifying events. We’re messy that way. But then, there could be other forces at work in that: Noah’s desire to get into politics and maybe become president one day doesn’t sound like a load of red flags at all, particularly not after the advice his grandmother gave him before her death.
We’re being directed to wonder whether Sinestro killed Hal, of course. Which is hilarious mostly due to cause of death—no way Sinestro uses a nine millimeter and executes him at point blank range, and no way Hal would take that without a fight. Again, it’s not messy enough. Certainly not for those two.
The eulogy is heartbreaking for the fact that you can imagine a much younger Hal drunkly typing the thing out (on a typewriter, no less), starting from a place of thinking it’s funny and trying to be funny, and finally getting to the point where he realizes that he’s gonna die someday. And trying to figure out how he feels about himself in light of that. It ends on the words “I hope I mattered,” effectively the same sentiment that leads to how viciously he protected his wielding of the ring down the line.
But the whole point of this exercise is that John Stewart tricked Guy Gardner into giving him access to Hal’s hologram for the purposes of solving the case. Now we’re getting somewhere—or we will next week.
The Emotional Electromagnetic Spectrum (or, Bits and Asides)
Image: John Johnson/HBO Max
Midway City is a DC midwest city in Michigan, though if memory serves, it was originally in Illinois. Though John Stewart canonically heralds from Detroit, DC prefers to have their own big cities, which causes a great deal of confusion when trying to figure out how anything works. (Is it weird that Metropolis and Gotham and Bludhaven exist in the same tristate area as New York City? Extremely. Why bother having real cities if you need a bunch of fake ones too.)
John rolling his eyes a little at Hal’s shotgun setup, but proceeding to use the setup and the gun several times anyhow.
Earl hearing Hal is dead from John’s phone call destroyed me. Also Hal keeping him in a tray right by his bed since he doesn’t have his greenhouse anymore? Stop that. Stop it right now.
The bird on the keychain for the storage unit as a signal to John? Hal, that’s adorable. Yet again, we learn more about the man through what he does than any of the bullshit he says.
That cube has a sense of humor, allowing the entire buttercup message to play before letting them know that it won’t take recordings. Let’s embarrass the man even in death—he sure deserves it.
Put a Green Lantern signal in the center of town and it still takes Guy Gardner half a day to make it over? For a guy who cares so much about branding and optics, he sure has a poor grasp of how timing looks. (Hal telling Guy to go climb a rope at their first meeting, and John immediately running with that joke—they are literally tag-teaming Guy while one of them is dead. I love them.)
And yet again with the HP references, this time from Guy about the space prison. It’s more ugly for happening twice. Knock it off.
Carol Ferris is Hal’s primary love interest in comics, and there are a lot of things about her appearance here that I love, including that Kerry called her for the funeral without question. (John somehow knows of her, too? Please explain.) I also love that while it didn’t work out between them, they clearly maintained some sort of friendship, and that she’s kept that eulogy all those years, which possibly says more about their relationship than anything else.[end-mark]
The post <i>Lanterns</i> Turns Toward a Mystery in “Bad Optics” appeared first on Reactor.