reactormag.com
Hell on the Gas Giant — Star Trek: Strange New Worlds: “Terrarium”
Movies & TV
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds
Hell on the Gas Giant — Star Trek: Strange New Worlds: “Terrarium”
Ortegas must find a way to survive on a hostile moon — alongside the enemy.
By Keith R.A. DeCandido
|
Published on September 4, 2025
Credit: Paramount+
Comment
0
Share New
Share
Credit: Paramount+
Ever since Hell on the Pacific was released in 1968, tons of stories have been told that riff on the Lee Marvin-Toshiro Mifune classic where they play, respectively, an American soldier and a Japanese soldier stuck alone on an island in the middle of World War II. The two have to overcome a language barrier, as well as a cultural one, and work together to survive.
The most famous science fictional riff on this concept is probably Barry B. Longyear’s multiple-award-winning 1979 novella Enemy Mine, which was adapted into a mediocre movie featuring Dennis Quaid and Louis Gossett Jr. in 1985. Star Trek has dipped into this well a lot, including twice on TNG (“The Enemy,” “Darmok”) and once on Enterprise (“Dawn”), plus variations on it on both DS9 (“The Ascent”) and Voyager (“Gravity”).
And now we add SNW to the list with an episode that only annoyed me a little bit, “Terrarium.”
Let’s get the annoying part out of the way. The episode’s climax has an appearance by a Metron (played by Dariush Zadeh) in yet another failed attempt to reconcile SNW with what was established in the original series’ “Arena.” I gotta say, I do not get the SNW producers’ obsession with the Gorn, especially since most of their episodes have been terrible. And this episode tries to make it look like what happened in “Arena” was the latest in a series of experiments by the Metrons involving the humans and Gorn, which almost makes sense, but still doesn’t reconcile the complete ignorance of the Gorn evinced by the Enterprise crew in the 1967 episode with the deep history with the Gorn the Federation has in the 2020s.
Having said that, it’s that history that makes this episode work. Ortegas has been suffering some serious PTSD since the trauma of escaping from the Gorn ship in “Hegemony, Part II,” seen most overtly in her insubordinate behavior in “Shuttle to Kenfori.” Here, she’s assigned to pilot a shuttlecraft to drop a subspace buoy in a technobabble phenomenon. However, a wormhole appears out of nowhere and the Archimedes falls through it. On the other side, the shuttle crashes on a moon orbiting a gas giant.
These types of shuttle-crash stories have many of the same beats, and it’s to the credit of “Terrarium’s” script, credited to co-executive producer Alan B. McElroy, that the familiar tropes remain compelling viewing. A big part of that is Melissa Navia’s charm. Ortegas is often fun to watch, and her snark-leavened desperation is particularly compelling viewing. So is her excitement—at one point, she cobbles together a water condenser, and her joy at it working is palpable.
However, while the condenser gives her water, and the shuttle itself provides shelter, she has no food (the emergency rations were trashed in the crash). So she explores, and comes across another crashed ship, which belongs to a single Gorn.
Thus starts the true part of the Hell on the Pacific/Enemy Mine riff. Ortegas has to get past her distrust of the Gorn, especially since the latter’s shuttle has a working force field that will hold off the predators on the planet. Ortegas even cobbles together a translator, which can only handle “agree” and “disagree” (an amusing riff on the yes/no wheelchair we saw Pike using in “The Menagerie,” the episode that introduced Pike to the viewership in 1966). It makes for some fun conversations between the two of them. (The Gorn can understand Ortegas, because she has learned the language of the enemy, but Ortegas needs the translator.) Between them, they’re able to eat and survive.
Eventually, Ortegas comes up with a crazy-ass plan to get the Enterprise’s attention, to wit, setting the moon’s atmosphere on fire.
Meanwhile, back on the Enterprise, Spock and Uhura are trying to come up with a way to determine if Ortegas is alive and if she can be rescued.
Credit: Paramount+
I’m really enjoying seeing Spock and Uhura’s friendship develop here. While the Bad Robot movies’ interpretation of the Spock-Uhura friendship as seen on the original series was to propose a romantic relationship between them—which is a perfectly valid interpretation, mind you—it isn’t the only interpretation possible. (The joys of 1960s TV and its lack of interest in developing characters.) Either way, though, it’s obvious from their interactions—in particular in “Charlie X,” “Is There in Truth No Beauty?” and “Who Mourns for Adonais?”—that there’s a deep abiding respect between the two, one that easily can speak for a friendship that dates back to before Kirk became captain of the Enterprise. Indeed, this episode—with Uhura’s out-of-the-box thinking in coming up with a solution, one that Spock then has to engineer—is a nice bit of prequility (a word I made up and continue to use) to “…Adonais?” in which Spock expresses what is obviously a long-held confidence in Uhura’s technical and scientific expertise. It’s said in the original series episode in relation to her fixing the communications console, and you can easily see that he’s basing it at least in part of things like her work in “Terrarium.”
That solution is to use the Enterprise itself to jam open the wormhole and use its sensors to find Ortegas. The probes they send in are too small and fragile to do the job.
Because there must be a ticking clock, the Enterprise has limited time to try to find and/or rescue Ortegas because they need to rendezvous with the Constellation to deliver a vaccine. At one point, Number One has to forcefully remind Uhura that there are thousands of people who will die without the vaccine and saving them is more important than saving one person. I appreciated this very much, as far too often in fiction, people who are in the opening credits are deemed more important than other people, and it’s morally bankrupt. (We’ve actually seen it twice in Trek, on the original series’ “The Galileo Seven” and DS9’s “Waltz.”) So Number One’s repeated reminders that they have a deadline is appreciated.
So is the continuity hit: the Constellation was established as another ship of the same class as the Enterprise in the original series’ “The Doomsday Machine,” and Pike even references Captain Decker. (He was a commodore in the original series episode, but that takes place six years in the future, so his promotion obviously happened in that timeframe…)
In the end, the Enterprise plugs open the wormhole, they see the moon on fire, and go and rescue their pilot.
I do have one other complaint about the episode, albeit a minor one, and one that may still be addressed (though there’s only one episode left this season, so I’m not confident), and that’s the rescue. La’an and two other security guards beam to the moon, and as soon as La’an sees the Gorn with Ortegas she fires on her and kills her.
While this is briefly touched on in the final scene in Ortegas’ quarters in her conversation with Uhura—with Ortegas saying that the Gorn was her friend and La’an is her friend, and she doesn’t know what to do with that—I’m incredibly disappointed that that wasn’t addressed in this here episode. La’an’s response is understandable, but also shows a spectacular inability to evaluate a situation, as there was no cause, none, for her to be firing on the Gorn until she knew more about what was going on. The Gorn wasn’t armed and wasn’t doing anything threatening. La’an’s own history makes her reaction understandable, but it wasn’t appropriate, and the episode’s unwillingness to address that is a minor flaw. Of course, there’s still a chance of it being addressed—if not next episode, then next season—but it’s a bit of a lack here.
Still, this is one of Trek’s better reworkings of Hell on the Pacific, and bravo to them for that. Even if it is yet another damn Gorn episode…[end-mark]
The post Hell on the Gas Giant — <i>Star Trek: Strange New Worlds</i>: “Terrarium” appeared first on Reactor.