spectator.org
Baseball Karen and the End of Western Society
I have a couple of seemingly unrelated stories to tell you. And my contention is that they’re not unrelated at all.
In Houston, Nation of Islam radicals are terrorizing Middle Eastern shopkeepers in black neighborhoods because they’re selling beer and Mad Dog 20/20 and Powerball tickets, which are all haram. It’s a special sort of obnoxious thing — those shopkeepers may or may not be Muslims, but they did generally leave the hellholes they came from in order to get away from sharia law, and now some black dude whose name used to be Bill Jones or something before he changed it, and who thought it was a cool idea to get a blood-red dye job on his goatee, is trying to impose it on them in the heart of Texas. (RELATED: A Texas City’s Quiet Claim to Islamic Territory)
ISLAMIFICATION: Houston area Islamic cleric demanding shopkeepers stop selling alcohol, pork and lottery tickets to comply with Islamic Sharia laws. pic.twitter.com/fYsnIbCBT9
— @amuse (@amuse) September 7, 2025
As best I can tell, nobody is very active in telling Mr. Soul Brother Ayatollah to cease and desist, and it’s making people very nervous.
Why? Well, it’s no secret what’s happening elsewhere in the collapsing West, where, for example, Keir Starmer just put a pro-Hamas jihadist into the job of Home Secretary. So you’ll know, that’s the cabinet-level agency in charge of not just the border but Great Britain’s intelligence community. (RELATED: Is Britain Becoming North Korea?)
And the rumor has it that when (not if) the Starmer government falls in the U.K., the next Labour prime minister there, as likely as not, will be Sadiq Khan.
I could regale you with stories of Islamic ascendancy in France, Germany, Canada, and a host of other places as well.
The West is rapidly declining vis-à-vis Islam. What began really before 9/11 but has accelerated ever since is reaching a phase in which it’s unmistakable. Our society no longer has the muscle to reject the advance of an alternative civilization that doesn’t seem to have a problem sponsoring things like rape gangs, so long as the victims are infidels. (RELATED: Radical Chic Continues at Georgetown)
Even if the cultural problem can be solved, and it can quite easily with a simple application of public will, the demographic problem is going critical if not terminal.
The non-Muslim birth rates in Western Europe tell that story.
How does a clearly superior civilization, such as the West boasts, vis-à-vis that of the Islamic world, simply disintegrate?
My answer might surprise you, and you might feel an instinct to reject it. I have a video to show you that you’ve likely seen…
Contrary to what’s on the internet, as of this writing, it doesn’t look like the identity of Baseball Karen has been solidified. She might actually be a school administrator — with that haircut, how can she not be? — but it doesn’t look like she was fired on Saturday, the day after this incident occurred.
It isn’t that Baseball Karen acted as she did. That isn’t the disease. It’s a symptom, though.
Here’s another video…
There has been a ton of scrutiny around Drew Feltwell, the father who was bullied into surrendering that home run ball to Baseball Karen.
Was his choice the right one?
I’m not going to say that this is the moral dilemma of our time, but to an extent?
It actually is, somewhat.
What would possess Feltwell with the idea that this was the right move? Why would he animatedly cower upon being assaulted — when Baseball Karen put her hand on his shoulder while aggressively berating him, that’s assault — over a baseball he procured for his son fair and square from the near-clutches of someone neither dextrous nor physically fit enough to get it for herself? And why would he confiscate a baseball from his own son to reward an obnoxious harpy?
Chivalry, that’s why. It’s been beaten into Western men’s heads that under no circumstances should you hit a woman, and rightly so. Societies where women are physically abused are brutal, backward, and unworthy societies, and they’ve rightly assumed a subservient place on the civilizational totem pole.
Except our concept of chivalry evolved from a standard that has disintegrated in modern times, which is that the chivalrous man observes a standard of behavior not so much around women but around ladies.
And there was a standard to which a woman purporting to be a lady must adhere.
A quite chivalrous 15th-century knight assaulted by Baseball Karen would likely have drawn on her and left her without a limb. Drew Feltwell knew he had no such option if he wanted to set a favorable example for his son and daughters. Particularly with cameras rolling all around him.
So what he was left with was what he did. And sure, it worked out.
Except Lincoln now knows that he’s consigned to play a subservient role in the face of all the Karens, baseball or otherwise, that he faces in his life.
And he will face an awful lot of them.
An astonishing poll by NBC News surfaced over the past couple of days…
Our NBC News Decision Desk poll asked Gen Z adults (18-29 years old) what they consider important to a successful life. The combination of gender and politics produced two very different sets of priorities: pic.twitter.com/xvm0t4IKaT
— Steve Kornacki (@SteveKornacki) September 8, 2025
Look at the results from those young women who voted for the Harris–Walz ticket, and what you see is a whole host of budding Baseball Karens. What they care about in life is career and money, then emotional stability (mostly because the cultural messages fed to them are designed to make them miserable, and do), and then friends.
Marriage and family come in last.
But when you prioritize aggressive pursuits in your 20s, you will end up angry and alone and stealing baseballs from children in front of Gaia and everyone in your 40s. This is known.
Supposedly, Baseball Karen was with a husband or boyfriend when Drew Feltwell outhustled her for that baseball. If so, either she was far too aggressive, or the husband/boyfriend was far too beta, for him to stop her from humiliating herself in seeking to take that ball away from young Lincoln. Neither is a particularly attractive possibility.
And this is what that led to…
For future reference, I’d suggest a third way of handling the situation, which would be to toss that baseball on the ground at Baseball Karen’s feet and tell her to pick it up if she wanted it so badly. And then the entire section would be laughing at her if she did — or if she didn’t as well, because what’s her next move? There’s no saving face at that point.
But that would be something you’d do if you were prepared for a confrontation like this, and most Western men aren’t.
Here was one Western man who was, and it happens that the situation involved a couple of aggressive Muslim males harassing a French Christian girl…
This how you deal with them?pic.twitter.com/UzoBsNPlWv
— NO CONTEXT VIDEOS (@Viralvid_89) August 21, 2025
The point being that we’re at a stage in our civilizational development in which we’ve warped our concept of chivalry, meaning the high standard of conduct between men and women that was socialized into all of us, into what’s essentially a suicide pact while encouraging a large segment of the female population to take advantage of that ideal.
The Baseball Karens are scamming the system, and now it’s broken.
You can’t ask the Drew Feltwells of the world to play second-class citizen to shrewish bullies in I-want-to-see-the-manager haircuts and Rachel Maddow glasses all their lives. That will not play.
Chivalry is ingrained in Western males still, but it’s fraying at the edges, and not surprisingly so…
There’s another astonishing bit of social research which made its way into the world of late, and it’s this…
All the men like Asian women; none of the men (even black men) like black women.
Why?
Of the four, which group is most associated with traditional families and traditional feminine roles? Asians. Which group is least thus associated? Black women.
You aren’t going to solve the demographic problems in the West this way. The Baseball Karens don’t reproduce. They don’t want to.
She didn’t have any kids at the game with her. She wanted that ball for herself, and she was just fine with making an ass of herself to get it. And when those around her gave her a piece of their minds for how she acted, she got aggressive with them as well.
And other than the internet finding out who she is and canceling her from the safety of our homes, which hasn’t happened as of this writing, nobody did anything.
Pull a stunt like that in public in Tehran or Riyadh or Jakarta, and a split lip is an optimistic result. In Miami, they give you memes.
It seems more civilized, but here’s the problem — you don’t win this way. You don’t stand up to tyranny, petty or otherwise, this way. This is how you still have people in face diapers at the airport, it’s how you have welfare queens throwing hands at a Chili’s, it’s how we allow Munchausen moms to trans their kids, and it’s how we have morons with red-dyed goatees trying to disrupt Powerball sales in the Houston hood.
C.S. Lewis put it best all those years ago, and his words still ring true…
“In a sort of ghastly simplicity we remove the organ and demand the function. We make men without chests and expect of them virtue and enterprise. We laugh at honour and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. We castrate and bid the geldings be fruitful.”
This is not to say that Drew Feltwell is a man without a chest. It is to say our society demands he surrender that chest in the face of a standard and an ideal which our culture has defiled.
We are castrating ourselves societally, and we are not fruitful.
But the red-bearded ayatollahs of the Houston slums, and the black-bearded ayatollahs of Rothingham and Marseille and Frankfurt are.
The Baseball Karens won’t save us. This much we know.
READ MORE from Scott McKay:
Peter Navarro, Lawfare, and the Death of Executive Privilege
They Don’t Really Want To Stand Behind Lisa Cook, Do They?
Last Year It Was Kamala, This Year It’s… Arch Manning?