reactormag.com
Peacemaker Opens Season Two With a Hilarious Retcon in “The Ties That Grind”
Movies & TV
Peacemaker
Peacemaker Opens Season Two With a Hilarious Retcon in “The Ties That Grind”
Peacemaker is clearly making some progress… was. He was making some progress.
By Emmet Asher-Perrin
|
Published on August 22, 2025
Image: Warner Bros.
Comment
0
Share New
Share
Image: Warner Bros.
Now that the DCU is squarely underway with the success of Superman, we’re going to hang out and chat about Peacemaker!
Recap
Image: Warner Bros.
We start with a brief recap of what occurred in season one, but when we get to the point where Leota Adebayo (Danielle Brooks) calls her mom for reinforcements, she asks Waller to send the Justice Gang. This time, as Peacemaker (John Cena) and company take an injured Emilia Harcourt (Jennifer Holland) off the field, he snaps “You’re late” to Guy Gardener (Nathan Fillion), Hawkgirl (Isabela Merced), and three more silhouetted figures who are very likely Mr. Terrific, Superman, and Supergirl.
In the dead of winter, Eagly demands to be taken out, but it’s too cold; Peacemaker opens the door to the quantum dimension in his dad’s old house where he currently lives, and Eagly flies away to an area Chris has never seen. He opens a new door with the same code and emerges in a large mansion, and sees his father (Robert Patrick) alive and well, who behaves in a manner shockingly kind toward him. Chris runs away back to his own universe. Six months on everyone is having a rough go of it; Adebayo’s wife has left her, Peacemaker is still considered a villain by everyone, and Harcourt has been blackballed from covert agencies. Chris interviews with the Justice Gang and meets Guy, Hawkgirl, and their benefactor Maxwell Lord (Sean Gunn), but hears them making fun of him and ignoring his answers to interview questions, not realizing that their mics are still on.
Chris goes to visit Harcourt and find out how her interview went (she got diagnosed with toxic masculinity by a psychiatrist), but really wants to talk about how they went on a boat together recently, got drunk, and hooked up. She tells him it doesn’t matter because she’s not interested, so he heads back home in a huff. After doing a bunch of cocaine, he pulls together a large orgy, and sits dazed amongst the action. John Economos (Steve Agee) is doing work for A.R.G.U.S. and gets a call from Adrian Chase (Freddie Stroma), who just wants to talk, and calls him every day. Turns out that Economos’ job is spying on Chris, which gets complicated when Agent Sasha Bordeaux (Sol Rodriguez) calls about a sensor ping—Chris has entered the quantum room. Economos goes to check it out and gets a picture of the room, but pretends he saw nothing except the orgy.
Bordeaux has been put on this case by Rick Flagg, Sr. (Frank Grillo) who is aware that Chris killed his son during Operation Starfish. He’s been keeping an eye on him ever since, and orders this mission upgraded to Priority One, saying he wants someone else added to the job because he doesn’t trust Economos. At the same time, Harcourt goes to a bar and starts a brawl after a man harasses her, and Chris enters the quantum room high. He makes it to the other door and walks through the mansion. When he goes outside, a truck pulls up to the house—it’s his brother Keith (David Denman), who never died. He and Auggie and Chris are a superteam together in this universe, and he sits with them both as they reminisce about things Chris did as a kid. Once they’re in bed, Chris keeps looking around the house, and finds a picture of him and Harcourt together.
He’s suddenly confronted by this universe’s version of him, who attempts to chase him down and murder him. Chris escapes to the quantum room, with alternate Peacemaker following. At home, Harcourt gets beat up and thrown out of the bar; she lies on the asphalt, staring up at the moon and smiling. In the quantum room, Chris fights alt-him, and accidentally triggers a little jetpack that smashes the guy into a spike on the ceiling. Alt-universe Peacemaker is dead.
Commentary
Image: Warner Bros.
While fully admitting that I can’t stand being this kind of person, I got excited as soon as Adebayo said “Justice Gang” and I realized we were about to witness an all-out retcon. It’s funnier in this iteration, too! Sorry, Guy and Kendra’s banter is a better tonal fit. Also, calling in Clark and Kara because Waller tells them this is an end-of-the-world deal, and this version of Superman seeing that field of bodies? He’s unwell. Even after they try to explain everything, you know he’s just chugging cocoa miserably.
What’s going on with Harcourt is honestly what I’m most interested in here. James Gunn only ever seems able to write one female character fully at a time (maybe two, when we get lucky?), and my biggest gripe with the first season was that Harcourt was barely a full person. Adebayo was all there and fantastic, but that only made the lack of characterization around Harcourt stand out—and yes, I know she’s very deliberately walled off and stoic, but you can still make those characters interesting! They do this for men all the time.
That said, if they focus in on Harcourt while Adebayo takes a back seat, I’ll still be real annoyed.
Harcourt getting “diagnosed” with toxic masculinity is simultaneously hilarious and tragic. It’s like the psychiatrist runs right up to the edge of the point and then leaps over the entirety of it. On paper it feels like it makes sense, but it’s so important to remember: No man on earth has to deal with what Harcourt deals with every time she sits down to have a beer. The anger and love of violence that we see on her off-hours is deliberately triggered over and over again by men who can’t let her drink a fucking Bud Light in peace, Chris included. The enjoyment of the fight, that comes after. (The smile is beautiful, let Jennifer Holland cook like this more often.) I feel like we’re bound to see some arguments claiming that she went looking for that fight, which again, misses the point entirely: Even if she did, the point is that Harcourt knows there are countless places in world where she simply isn’t allowed to exist in a neutral state. That’s the issue.
Just because Chris has been working on himself doesn’t mean he’s the right match for her, or that she wants a match in the first place. Hopefully, the show keeps that in mind as we continue, now that alt-universe Harcourt is in the picture.
The Justice Gang interview is great here, not for the cameos, but for continuing to show the ways that Chris Smith often doesn’t fit the shape of this world, even when he’s trying. (Which runs adorably parallel to Adrian calling Economos every day?) Obviously killing your dad doesn’t fix everything magically; now he’s got to do the real work of divesting himself of all the terrible things his dad instilled in him, and that’s going to take… I mean, forever, in a way. Peacemaker was forty when he finally got away from his abuser. That’s a deep hole to climb out of.
I do like the suggestion that the alternate universe isn’t perfect by any means; the other Peacemaker nearly murders Chris without even bothering to ask who this guy is or what’s going on. Auggie still has hints of callousness about him, and Keith is clearly the balance between his younger brother and father whether he wants to be or not. As we reach deeper into that universe, I’m hoping the shine dulls if you’re paying attention.
Also, there’s the Rick Flagg, Sr. of it all. Yeesh.
Keeping the Peace (Thoughts and Asides)
Image: Warner Bros.
The new opener is set to Foxy Shazam’s “Oh Lord,” and has a far more dour vibe than season one’s jam, dance included. Love ending with everyone stacked in a pile. It’s foreboding, even if it is intended more metaphorically.
Genuinely, the most impressive skill Peacemaker possesses is his ability to pull together an orgy with so many people that quickly. It was nice to see an array of body types/sexual orientations/interactions, but that was the thing I got stuck on. Chris Smith speed dialing the local orgy crowd, high on cocaine, and everyone shows up? Imagine if your DnD group was that ready to go.
This is the second time on this show that someone has shown a colleague inappropriate photos when they meant to show them a work related thing, so I’ve got to assume that this is either James Gunn’s greatest personal fear, or it’s happened to him a lot.
“Hot People Save Hot Planets” is an objectively great thing to put on a shirt, where can we all get one?
My favorite part of the episode, hands down, is Chris griping that Guy Gardener talked about him sucking dick like it’s a bad thing when “that’s fucking a compliment!” Because it is! (Also, gimme a break, you expect us to believe that Guy Gardener has never sucked a dick before…)
Okay, that’s it for this week. Tune in next time![end-mark]
The post <i>Peacemaker</i> Opens Season Two With a Hilarious Retcon in “The Ties That Grind” appeared first on Reactor.