www.historyisnowmagazine.com
Marie Antoinette - The Queen Who Wouldn’t Behave
It is a cold, crisp, afternoon in Paris. The year is 1793. A young woman is brought before the guillotine, her hands bound behind her. She wears a plain white gown- not her usual Rococo style but times have changed. Once the apple of the French people’s eye, their opinions of her have soured. Her fate sealed by the court of public opinion. Her official crime was treason. Her real crime is being a woman in power.From her birth to the high life at Versailles, to her inevitable beheading, Marie Antoinette was set up to rise high — and fall even further. This article re-examines how a woman who dared to be outspoken and powerful in a world that demanded her silence became a symbol of excess and corruption – a French queen condemned by a society that shaped her through power she never asked for. Yet what if Marie Antoinette’s downfall reveals more about the world she lived in than about the woman herself?Sophie Riley explains.
Marie Antoinette with a Rose by Élisabeth Vigée Le Brun, 1783.From Princess to Political PawnBorn into a life of luxury in 1755 Vienna, Maria Antonia, the youngest of the Habsburg House was never intended to rule. However, her strict education directed her to use her body, charm and fertility to secure not only an heir to the throne but to strengthen the already established Franco-Austrian alliance.Her fate was sealed long before her marriage to the future King of France, Louis XVI, in 1770. Fourteen years earlier, the first Treaty of Versailles had set the terms of this diplomatic union. Her marriage was not one of love but of statecraft. From the beginning, her body and identity served political ends far beyond her control. Vienna to VersaillesAt the age of fourteen, Maria Antonia crossed the border of Vienna into France and was transformed into Marie Antoinette. From that moment on, nothing Austrian could remain- not in her name, appearance or manners.At Versailles, she was subjected to a strict schedule governed by expectation and constant scrutiny from Louis’s family and the French court, whose approval she was expected to gain. As the Dauphine of France, she was expected to embody obedience, fertility and femininity.However, her foreign roots isolated her as she was continuously misunderstood and mocked by the French Court. Seeking comfort, Marie Antoinette secluded herself within her private apartment surrounding herself only with a small circle of trusted companions. Her self-imposed isolation excluding in her early years of power would later fuel the backlash that she endured as Queen of France. A Queen Under FireIn her early years at Versailles, Marie Antoinette was adored by the public. Thousands flocked to Paris in 1773 to see the young Dauphine and Dauphin. Admiration, however, soon turned to suspicion as rumours circled about her love of fashion and false claims were made about her gambling habits at her home in the Petit Trianon.Branded Madam Deficit, she became a symbol of excess despite her continuous donations to charities across France. Whether these rumours were true or not was irrelevant- the people deemed her guilty. This marked the beginning of her downfall.The most damaging attacks came not from court whispers but from a powerful, growing force of anonymous writers outside the palace known as the press. Pamphlet WarfareCenturies before social media and the tabloids, scandalous pamphlets known in French as Libelles emerged as a powerful tool of political propaganda against Marie Antoinette. These widely circulated texts would turn Marie Antoinette from a foreign fashion icon to a symbol of moral corruption.Sensational titles like Les Nouvelles de la Cour (1775) insinuated that the Dauphine’s close relationship with Princess Lamballe was far more deviant and intimate than they presented publicly. Seemingly innocent outings and friendships were reframed as scandalous. Furthermore, the late consummation of their marriage further fuelled the vicious rumours of Marie Antoinette causing the Kings impotence.At the height of their fame libelles entitled L’Autrichienne en Goguettes ou l’Orgie Royale (“The Austrian Woman and Her Friends in the Royal Orgy,” 1789) implied that the Queen was insatiable, manipulative and unfaithful. These pamphlets portrayed her as a corruptor of children, seducing the King and engaging in orgies in the Petit Trianon. Though entirely manufactured their impact was profound. In the eyes of the French people, she was now Madam Deficit a symbol of excess and moral corruption. The libelles did not just damage her reputation beyond repair but painted her as the monster Queen, the one who would face the guillotine two decades later. The Scandal She Never CommittedIn 1785, Marie Antoinette was wrongly accused of defrauding the Crown Jewellers of a diamond necklace that cost 1.6 million livres. In reality her signature had been forged by con-woman Jeanne De la Motte- Valois who exploited the Queen’s fragile reputation to carry out fraud.Although she was pardoned by Parliament, Marie Antoinette’s reputation never recovered. Pornographic pamphlets painted her as sexually immoral and corrupt- the perfect villain for a country on the brink of bankruptcy. Many people were quick to find her guilty as the libelles created an image that fitted her perfectly. For France it was entirely believable that the foreign Queen would spend money furiously while ordinary Parisians struggled to afford bread. Her acquittal would reinforce that because of her status she was above the law; she was also shielded by privilege and therefore dangerous. The whole affair became less about truth and more about the power of public perception. The case confirmed to her critics that she was a symbol of corruption and a woman who could not be trusted — the perfect villain for a nation on the brink of revolution. The Price of Being Marie AntionetteShe is remembered by a phrase that she never uttered “let them eat cake.” Her spending exaggerated beyond recognition and her personality reduced to a caricature of frivolity.The reality, however, is far more complex. Marie Antoinette paid the ultimate price with her life- not because she was corrupt, but that she was dominant woman in a society that expected her to remain submissive. Her people refused to see her as a young woman trapped by duty in a judgemental patriarchal society.She was not just a Queen; she was a powerful woman who was turned into a symbol and ultimately the perfect scapegoat. And what if that same question still applies today: do women in power reveal more about themselves — or about the societies that judge them? Did you find that piece interesting? If so, join us for free by clicking here.
New Posts (Home)
ChatBox
Popular Posts 
Game Zone
Top PodCasts
