reactormag.com
Alien: Earth Stacks Betrayal Upon Betrayal in “Emergence”
Movies & TV
Alien: Earth
Alien: Earth Stacks Betrayal Upon Betrayal in “Emergence”
The aliens were good again this week.
By Leah Schnelbach
|
Published on September 17, 2025
Credit: FX / Hulu
Comment
0
Share New
Share
Credit: FX / Hulu
Episode Seven of Alien: Earth is titled “Emergence” and was written by Noah Hawley and Maria Melnik and directed by Dana Gonzales.
Let’s Dissect a Still-Quivering Facehugger
We begin in Slightly’s room, where Slightly has stashed Arthur under his bed with the sheet pulled down to hide him.
You can imagine how disappointed I was when I saw they hadn’t stayed in the air duct, but one can’t have everything in this life.
It was also a brilliant way to underscore just how much of a child Slightly is, and to twist the knife a little harder that he’s being manipulated so cruelly by Morrow. But not nearly as hard as the knife twist when poor Slightly tries to help Arthur drink some green juice through a straw, then panics as the facehugger tightens its grip on his neck.
Smee shows up and pounds on the door until Slightly lets him in. Smee sees him. Smee freaks out. But within moments Smee has been roped into helping carry Arthur down to the beach. There follows a tonal tightrope that I really enjoyed. The two boys dart through hallways carrying Arthur between them, ducking around soldiers, and generally behaving like an even darker version of Weekend at Bernie’s, until they run into Kirsh. He seems disappointed in them for not thinking to take the secure elevator—that’s the quickest route to the beach. They scurry through the jungle, and when they see armed guards they drop Arthur’s body and hide behind some bushes. When the coast is clear, they realize that somehow, Arthur’s body disappeared. Then the shell of the facehugger falls on them from a tree, and there’s Arthur, groggy but seemingly fine. As they walk to the beach, they feed Arthur lies about an evacuation and gas leak to try keep him moving, while he muses on his fight with Dame, and how he doesn’t want that to be her last memory of him. And then, for a moment, the show goes full 90s sitcom: Arthur tells the boys he knows they’re lying to him, that he loves them, and that what they’re going to do is go back to the facility and tell him what’s going on so he can help them. He holds out his hands so they can walk together, tells them everything’s going to be OK… and the baby Xenomorph explodes out of his chest and he collapses screaming and choking on his own blood.
Credit: FX / Hulu
Slightly runs after the alien but loses it in the bushes. Smee screams at Slightly because he said Arthur was going to be okay. Both boys are covered in blood and terrified. In the end, there’s not much else to do but carry Arthur’s corpse to the beach anyway.
Meanwhile. Kirsh finds Isaac’s body (and it’s notable that Kirsch calls him Isaac, and only switches to “Tootles” when Boy Kavalier doesn’t know who the hell “Isaac” is), supervises the workers who capture the Alien Flies, and then calls Boy Kavalier in to look at the tape. Unsurprisingly, as soon as the Boy Genius sees that Optipus Sheep knowingly sabotaged Isaac, he insists on holding a private interview with the alien. But before they can talk, Wendy shows up. She’s shocked and horrified that Isaac is dead, and that the Lost Boys can even die. Kirsh and Boy Kavalier try to stop her from storming out of the lab to warn her siblings, but she chirps at the Xenomorph and it bangs on the glass at her request. Seeing Boy Kavalier realize, if only for a second, that he may have made an error is pretty sweet.
Joe goes to Wendy, and she agrees to his escape plan. She insists on collecting the other kids, but Curly digs in her heels and refuses to leave. Never Land is the best place she’s ever lived. Nibs wants to stay, then decides that if she stays she’ll get eaten by bugs and become a ghost, and comes along anyway, clutching her doll. Wendy, being really really intelligent, and also able to hack the island’s computer system, turns her Teen Xenomorph loose.
That should buy them some time.
The meeting at the beach does not go well. Morrow rises from the water with a whole team of soldiers, coordinating with other spots on the island. He sneers at Slightly, who says that as an adult he has to own up to it when he’s made a mistake. Then he takes Smee and Slightly hostage and marches them back toward the facility.
Boy Kavalier and Kirsh confront Dame Sylvia, who insists she knew nothing about Arthur giving Joe the boat codes. Boy Kavalier storms out of the room and snaps at Kirsh to be useful. He regards Dame Sylvia, who regards him back.
Joe, Wendy, and Nibs come upon a graveyard where the Lost Boys’ human bodies were buried, with markers and everything. Joe tries to clean Marcy’s grave, Nibs crouches on her and muses that she didn’t really survive, Wendy stares at Marcy’s headstone.
They keep going.
Meanwhile, the Baby Xenomorph who just vacated Arthur’s chest cavity has been trapped by Boy Kavalier’s soldiers.
And Boy Kavalier is—
For fucks sake.
Boy Kavalier’s moved Optipus Sheep into another room. He stands in front of it, staring into its eye, and speaking with it. Atom Eins tries to suggest that all of this is a bad idea, but as usual Boy does not listen to Atom Eins. He demands a pen, writes pi, and asks Optipus to indicate the next number.
Optipus does so, first with hoof stomps, then with shit.
Naturally Boy Kavalier responds to this display of alien intelligence by deciding it’ll be a swell idea to move Optipus into a better body—“someone who can talk, and use a toilet”—and as Atom Eins says he’ll compile a list, Boy Kavalier’s eyes light up and he says he’s thought of someone.
It’s Joe, right? Unless he’s going to go grab Dame Sylvia for this. Or maybe Boy’s decided he wants Atom Optipus as an advisor.
Meanwhile, Dame’s asleep on a chair—okay what’s going on? Why is everyone acting so weird in this episode. The kids have escaped, your husband’s been driven off the island (as far as you know), you were just threatened by a synth, and you’ve fallen asleep curled up in a chair like a mom reading a boring book club pick? She wakes up because Curly’s standing in front of her crying, and even though she should know that the kids’ trackers are off, and that Isaac is dead, Dame seems confused that Curly is upset. The girl climbs into the chair and she holds her, and Curly calls her “Mum”.
Credit: FX / Hulu
Joe, Wendy, and Nibs are stopped by more of Morrow’s soldiers, which does not go well for them when Wendy chirps at her Large Xenomorph Son and he annihilates them. Nibs is excited, Joe is horrified, Wendy wipes the blood off the Xenomorph’s face and tells it to follow them but stay hidden.
At least, she thinks that’s what she told it.
Morrow marches Slightly and Smee into the facility, only to find a large portion of Prodigy’s security forces waiting for him, along with Kirsh, who’s holding the new baby Xenomorph in an adorable little cat carrier. Morrow holds a gun to Slightly’s head but Kirsh tells him that nobody likes a sore loser, and Morrow gives up. Kirsh tells the boys that they’re grounded.
Joe, Wendy, and Nibs reach the boat. Unsurprisingly, Joe’s fellow Search & Rescue people are lying in wait, along with a bunch of other security forces. One of them throws Nibs’ doll in the water so she tears the woman’s heart out, then starts to wring Siberian’s neck. Wendy starts to call the Xenomorph, Joe stops her, and then shoots Nibs with his energy gun, seemingly frying and killing her. “WHAT DID YOU DO???” Wendy screams at her brother, who appears to have chosen a side.
In This Space, Everyone Can Hear My Opinions
Outstanding in its field. (Credit: FX / Hulu)
I’m severely disappointed in the lack of ducts this week.
As fun as it is to see the Xenomorph rustling around in trees and grasses, it’s just doesn’t have the same kick as when one camouflages itself in a big mess of industrial tubes.
With that out of the way, I have a lot of feelings about this week’s episode.
One of my concerns as the show races toward its finale is the the last few episodes could feel either overstuffed, or like they were padding. This one, at times, felt like both. The idea that multiple troops of kids could wander around the island, with soldiers occasionally spawning out of nowhere, but then not seeing the assorted hybrids duck behind bushes, began to feel a little, um, Keystone Cops-esque to me.
I’m frustrated by the idea that Joe though he could walk to the boat in broad daylight with no plan, and that there wouldn’t be any security measures—even with the codes, each hybrid is seen as property and costs billions of dollars, obviously even if they somehow got off the island, they’d then be hunted by one of the five richest people on Earth.
I’m also suffering whiplash from Kirsh’s decisions. He used Slightly as bait, I guess? But how could he know that Morrow would come back to the facility with the boys, that his team would catch the chestburster first, that Arthur would die before reaching the rendezvous point, etc. etc? What happened when he was left alone with Dame Sylvia? Did he tell her about her husband? Is he actually plotting against Boy Kavalier at all, or simply observing?
Credit: FX / Hulu
As for what I loved this week, everything to do with Slightly, Smee, Arthur, and the chestburster was perfect. The way the two Lost Boys act like kids who are hiding something from their parents in a sitcom, the way Arthur tries to impart Dad Wisdom right before he explodes, the mercilessness of Morrow, Slightly speedrunning his own personal LARP of Come and See, Smee losing it over Arthur’s corpse on the beach—all of it was harrowing and hilarious and perfect. Especially, I thought, that the show stay with Arthur’s body after the soldiers marched the boys away. The fact that the camera held on Arthur’s face as he sank under the water was a beautiful reminder that he was, in fact, a human person. He didn’t deserve any of this.
This is made worse when we see that the his last attempt at doing something good has been, most likely, completely thwarted by Prodigy’s security forces. Joe was set on getting Wendy off the island because he still thought of her as his sister. He already didn’t care about the other Lost Boys. And between finding the children’s graves, seeing Wendy communicate with the alien, and finally watching Nibs attack a human, it seems like a switch finally flipped for him. I think he’s thrown in his lot with the meatbags.
BUT. Unlike Joe, seeing Wendy speak with her Long Teen Xenomorph Son filled me with joy.
And watching Boy Kavalier think that he can actually forge a relationship with Optipus makes me very hopeful for next week’s episode.
I want her to burrow into the Boy Genius’s head And I want her to become THE PRESIDENT OF EARTH.
On Immort(AI)lity
Credit: FX / Hulu
Nibs decides to come with them because she doesn’t want to “become a ghost”, but when the group stumbles upon the Lost Boy graveyard, it forces her to wonder if she’s too late. Nibs sees her old name, her Before name, on a tombstone that was carefully placed over a body that she kind of remembers.
“We’re here,” Wendy reassures her.
“I don’t think I am any more,” Nibs replies.
And then we see, once again, that a hybrid can be fried. This is after, if I understood correctly, Kirsh informed Boy Kavalier that they hadn’t made a copy of Isaac yet, so presumably this is real, permanent, death. Once again the Boy Genius has turned in an half-assed a project.
But are these the kids? Or copies of brain patterns? Is Arthur right, that he and Dame are just complicit in their murder?
The kids think they’re the kids. Curly calls Dame “Mum”. Nibs flips out because someone throws her toy away. But they’re not just behaving like they’ve been programmed to act like any human children—Wendy responds instantly to threats against her brother, just as Slightly does when Morrow threatens his mother.
Boredom’s Not a Burden Anyone Should Bear
This week’s episode ended on one of my favorite songs ever, Queens of the Stone Age’s “A Song for the Dead”, off their 2002 stone cold fucking classic Songs for the Deaf.
But is it for Arthur, or Nibs, or everyone on that island?
David 8 Was Right
Credit: FX / Hulu
Kirsh has hung back and observed, taunted Morrow enough to make this war even more personal than it already was, used Slightly as bait, secured the second chestburster, saved Slightly and Smee from Morrow, and, I assume, deployed the security forces to head Joe, Wendy, and Nibs off.
All while Boy Kavalier makes googly eyes at an alien that wants to colonize his brain, Joe screws up a not-very-good escape plan, and all the hybrids fall apart emotionally. Well, except Wendy, who seems to be considering switching the alien team herself.
Whatever Happened to “Save the Cat”?
Credit: FX / Hulu
I don’t want Boy Kavalier to offer Optipus some other, human, less-cute body! Get away from her! Leave her in the sheep!
Scattered Transmissions in the Void of Space!
Credit: FX / Hulu
Everyone’s acting this week is incredible. I don’t think I’ve said that enough, but Alex Lawther and Timothy Olyphant seem to be an Acting Through Micro-Expression arms race, and whoever loses, we all win. Erana James, Lily Newmark, Adarsh Gourav, and Jonathan Ajayi are all pulling off an extraordinary at balancing being children in adult bodies who are trying to act like adults, and this week Gourav and Ajayi’s terror and panic over Arthur’s death was heartbreaking. And David Rysdahl as Arthur!!!
Joe’s perspective: Instead of leaving for med school on Mars, this promising young doctor was trapped in service to the Prodigy Corporation, was rescued a synth who is seemingly also his dead sister while being attacked by aliens, was threatened personally by the richest person on the planet (who also removed his lung??), watched his sister commune with an alien, betrayed the richest person on the planet to try and free her, and has now begun to think that this isn’t his sister at all, but rather a synthetic clone.
Wendy’s perspective: She kept an eye on Joe throughout all their time apart, watched Ice Age with him remotely, nurtured her memories of their childhood together, rescued him from an alien, shared her abilities with him, talked the richest person into the world into letting them live together again, facilitated getting him off an island full of dangerous people, and has now been betrayed utterly by the one person she thought she could trust.
This is a world where if your corporate overlord fires you, you have to say goodbye to your wife forever.
I realize I’m not so hot on humanity at the moment, but I still think I’m on Wendy’s side here. Just because Joe gets squeamish around a little alien carnage, that’s no reason to betray your possibly-a-clone sister during the escape YOU pushed for. And who wouldn’t want an alien? I bet this one could be good.
If there isn’t an after credits scene of Wendy getting the Xenomorph a pup cup next week, I’m going to be super pissed.
Quotes!
Credit: FX / Hulu
Curly (to Wendy, about Boy Kavalier): “Don’t talk about him like you understand him.”
Kirsh (to Smee and Slightly): “What are you doing going that way? The quickest way to the beach is the secure elevator.”
Arthur Sylvia (to Smee and Slightly): “It’s going to be OK.” [alien bursts from chest]
Boy Kavalier (to Atom Eins, about Optipus): “You’re right! We should switch it into a person, someone who can talk, and use a toilet—one of the scientists maybe? No, a mold-scrubber! Someone with a low IQ so we can see the difference!”
Morrow: “This isn’t over.”
Kirsh: “Nothing ever is.”
Kirsh (to Smee and Slightly): “You two are grounded.”
[end-mark]
The post <em>Alien: Earth</em> Stacks Betrayal Upon Betrayal in “Emergence” appeared first on Reactor.