reactormag.com
“All you have to do is look up at the stars” — Star Trek: Strange New Worlds: “New Life and New Civilizations”
Movies & TV
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds
“All you have to do is look up at the stars” — Star Trek: Strange New Worlds: “New Life and New Civilizations”
With prequels, certain story beats are inevitable, but can still make an impact…
By Keith R.A. DeCandido
|
Published on September 11, 2025
Credit: Paramount+
Comment
1
Share New
Share
Credit: Paramount+
Here’s the problem with doing a prequel with established characters: we know what’s going to happen to a whole lot of them, which puts barriers up on certain story notions. It doesn’t completely limit storytelling. For one thing, storytelling generally resists attempts to limit it. And even when you know characters’ futures, there’s still plenty of room for powerful tales. As evidence, I point to, not just this very show, but also two fantastic recent examples, Better Call Saul and Star Wars: Andor.
But there are story angles that are closed off, and also certain conclusions that are foregone. On this show, we know that, at the very least, Pike, Spock, Uhura, Scotty, Chapel, Korby, M’Benga, and both Kirks will still be around several years’ hence.
And we know enough details about them (some more than others, obviously) that certain avenues are, if not cut off, at least severely limited.
The third-season finale of SNW addresses one of those avenues, as we have to come to the inevitable end of the Pike-Batel relationship.
I chose the word inevitable there quite specifically. This relationship was doomed from the start, because Pike obviously wasn’t with Batel in “The Menagerie”; indeed, she wasn’t even a factor. If Pike had a significant other, that’s something that would’ve come up, especially given Pike’s final fate, which was to live out his life on Talos IV with Vina, their respective injuries masked by the Talosians’ telepathy.
So at some point over the course of SNW, the Pike-Batel relationship was going to have to end.
I find myself wondering if this was the plan all along, or if they were at first going to do something more mundane to just break them up. The problem is, Anson Mount and Melanie Scrofano have had such superlative chemistry that just having them break up was going to be either unconvincing or would require mangling one of their characters enough to make it convincing, which would be unsatisfying.
Instead, we close out the third season with a payoff to the cure for the Gorn infestation Batel received in “Shuttle to Kenfori” as well as the fight that broke out between Batel and the Vezda-possessed corpse of Nurse Gamble in “Through the Lens of Time.”
Over the course of this episode we learn that the fancy-shmancy rare flower that they retrieved from Kenfori to cure Batel didn’t just hybridize the Gorn DNA with hers, but instead transformed her into the guardian that was keeping the Vezda imprisoned on Vadia IX (or, more accurately, in the interdimensional prison that can be accessed via Vadia IX). The Vezda that possessed Gamble has been hiding in the Enterprise medical computer (as implied by the very last shot of “Through the Lens…”), and managed to reconstruct Gamble’s body from the medical transporter buffer. He has gone to Skygowan, another world from which he can access the prison (and where Korby is right now).
Batel has come to realize her purpose—backed up by a medical scan that shows that she’s now genetically identical to the guardian in the prison—and so has to confront the Vezda and reimprison them.
So we do lose her, but it’s a sacrifice she makes in order to keep the galaxy safe from the Vezda. And just to remind us how awful they are, Gamble deliberately torments M’Benga as much as he can, and also makes a large chunk of the Skygowan population gouge their eyes out to prepare them for being possessed by the Vezda. Fun people, the Vezda are…
Just before the final battle between Batel and the Vezda, she sends her and Pike into—er, something. It might be a dream sequence, it might be an alternate timeline, it might be a Talosian-style illusion. But whatever it is, it, “Inner Light”-style, has Pike and Batel living out their happily ever after. They marry, they have a kid (and a dog). When Pike goes on the cadet cruise on the Class-J ship, they’re both stunned when he doesn’t get hit with delta rays and instead gets out of it unscathed. They live together to old age, and only when she’s on her deathbed does she reveal the truth: that these memories will stay with both of them to remind them each what they are fighting for.
Credit: Paramount+
Amazingly, this adds further texture to the framing sequence of “The Menagerie.” Throughout Part 1 of that two-parter, Pike is constantly telling Spock “no” when Spock kidnaps him to take him to Talos IV. Pike’s foreknowledge of his confinement to a convalescent chair back in Discovery’s “Through the Valley of Shadows” and his subsequent acceptance of that (despite some hiccups, notably in “A Quality of Mercy”) explains why he was so reluctant to go along with Spock’s crazy-ass plan.
Now we have another reason: he already has detailed memories of a happy life with Batel. He knows that he’ll be trapped in a body that will be ravaged by radiation so much that he will be in constant pain, but he also will refuse Spock’s help, because he has these memories.
I also have to give props to the script, credited to two of the show’s executive producers, Dana Horgan & Davy Perez, and especially to the direction by the superlative Maja Vrvilo (one of the best of the regular slate of directors Trek has been using the last eight years) for the dream sequence/illusion/alternate reality/what-the-hell-ever. The cuts to show the passage of time are simple and subtle, and I especially love the use of knocking on the door as a motif.
I have heard arguments that Batel is fridged here, and I can see the argument, but I’m not quite there to accept it for the very reasons I outlined above. The relationship was always doomed thanks to Batel’s absence from “The Menagerie.” She needed to be written out, and this way she goes out in a blaze of glory, giving Pike a lovely mental gift and also saving a shit-ton of lives.
Besides, this doesn’t really fit the criteria. A fridging is a gratuitous death of a female character whose death’s sole plot purpose is to motivate the hero. That doesn’t apply here. Pike is a bystander to her sacrifice—and also an aid to it. It’s the death of a hero, not the death of a girlfriend. (Having said that, I can see the argument. Feel free to discuss this further in the comments…)
One of the side-plots involves our heroes needing to open up the portal on Skygowan that leads to the interdimensional prison. Scotty and Pelia hit on the notion of ship’s phasers, but a single ship only has about fifty percent of the power. So they do it with two ships, since the Farragut is also nearby, and Captain V’Rel apparently is indebted enough to the Enterprise crew for saving her life in “The Sehlat Who Ate Its Tail” that she’s willing to go along with this.
Because apparently Horgan and Perez don’t understand how computers work, we are told that a mind-meld between two pilots is the only way to coordinate the two ships’ joint firing solution. (It would make much more sense for an independent computer system to control both ships simultaneously, but I guess that violates Trek’s long-standing inconsistent animus against automation.) Spock and Kirk are the ones who must mind-meld. First off, let me give major credit to the script for queer-coding the shit out of the scene in which Spock and Ortegas approach Kirk, which I’m sure made legions of slash fanfic writers giddy with glee. (I certainly chortled mightily.) And second of all, for all that it was dumb, it was lovely watching Paul Wesley and Ethan Peck talk in stereo as they did the thing.
The episode does not end with a cliffhanger, thank goodness, nor even with a surprise ending or any other kind of tease. It simply concludes with the Enterprise going off on their next mission. Which is as it should be.
Next week, I’ll do an overview of this very uneven third season.[end-mark]
The post “All you have to do is look up at the stars” — <i>Star Trek: Strange New Worlds</i>: “New Life and New Civilizations” appeared first on Reactor.