reactormag.com
Peacemaker Creates New Villains in “Like a Keith in the Night”
Movies & TV
Peacemaker
Peacemaker Creates New Villains in “Like a Keith in the Night”
Making the Nazi universe a gag is… maybe not the best decision?
By Emmet Asher-Perrin
|
Published on October 3, 2025
Image: Jessica Miglio/HBO Max
Comment
0
Share New
Share
Image: Jessica Miglio/HBO Max
Is anyone really surprised that the snacks in a Nazi dimension suck?
Recap
Image: Jessica Miglio/HBO Max
Harcourt points out that not only is there a swastika on the flag here, but a copy of Mein Kampf on every desk, and a big old mural of Hitler on the wall. When Emilia comes in and demands Harcourt’s arrest, Chris and Harcourt begin to fight their way out of A.R.G.U.S. Adrian learns from his alt-self that they have to find Adebayo immediately; in this reality, people of color are put in labor camps. Abebayo is running from an angry mob and jumps into a pool. On the other side, she finds Judomaster, who helps her out before electrifying the pool and killing everyone in it. Keith goes home on his dad’s orders and find Economos tied to a chair, while August tries to explain that they have to round up everyone who came with this man, or their quantum door will be discovered.
Judomaster brings Adebayo to a house where the people are on vacation, and tells her what he’s learned about this reality. They decide to hole up until nightfall when they can head back to the Smith house and escape, and begin a game of Scrobble. They wind up talking about dreams and how Adebayo maybe ignored her wife’s for her own. Adebayo also defends Chris to him, and points out that he’s cheesy, but a good guy. Chris and Harcourt are escaping in the Peacecycle and have a moment of contentment before they’re surrounded by cops. August and Keith arrive and murder all of them, taking them back to the house. Back in their reality, Flag and Bordeaux get Sydney Happersen (Stephen Blackehart) at Luthor’s direction, and ask him to find the dimension door, which he does in short order. It’s in Washington and much more stable than anything that Luthorcorp had access to.
At the Smith house, Chris tries to explain why he came to this reality and what happened to their Chris. Keith is furious about his brother’s murder, but August tells him to calm down. There’s a knock at the door and alt-Larry Fitzgibbon (Lochlyn Munro) asks if he can search the house. August refuses to allow it until they’ve got a warrant. The cops back away to a half distance. Adebayo and Rip are scoping the place out when both Vigilantes show up, and they decide to try and sneak in, despite all the guys wanting to kill the cops.
August tells Chris and Harcourt and Economos to gather their friends and leave; he’ll change the door code once they leave. Keith can’t believe his father would let them go without vengeance, but August believes Chris. Harcourt calls him a Nazi, and he insists that he isn’t one, and that he fights what he can. Alt-Vigilante breaks in and stabs August in the neck repeatedly, killing him. The disturbance gives the cops probable cause to enter and there’s a firefight. Chris is stunned that his dad is maybe not a Nazi here, but his friends are desperately trying to get him through the door. Keith goes after them and tries to kill Chris, but his friends come to his aid. The sight of everyone trying to murder his brother makes Chris scream and beg them all to stop; he holds Keith and thinks of all the people who’ve died because of him, apologizing to Keith and insisting that he is what’s wrong and evil.
Adebayo insists that they leave, and the group makes to escape. Harcourt plans to kill Keith so he can’t follow, but they’re stopped by the cops. Keith gets medical attention, still alive. In their universe, A.R.G.U.S. has a crew waiting outside Adrian’s home. The group exit and Chris gives Flag the quantum door device, telling him that the group convinced him to do this. They’re all shocked, and watch as Chris is arrested and driven away.
Commentary
Image: Jessica Miglio/HBO Max
Here’s the issue. The whole reveal of August Smith being a halfway decent guy who has to calm Keith out of taking revenge until his own death feels like it’s there for “twist” purposes in order to give Chris the maximum amount of emotional trauma. I understand the purpose in it, but I do think it could have been set up better, and am kind of resenting how rote the whole turn is as an origin story for Keith as a villain. Because you know he’s coming back, whether it’s in the final episode or a later season, should they get one.
Additionally, they’ve bowled over all this great work they’ve built up because of the traumatic experience, and then brushed off what the trauma itself was initially about! It’s no longer relevant that Chris’ friends came to get him because he’s busy thinking about the murder of his alt-universe not-a-Nazi dad and the near-murder of his brother. But even more importantly, his scream of “What the fuck is wrong with all of us?” after the people dearest to him attempt to kill Keith is immediately written off as his problem; now Chris has got it in his head that he’s the one who brings death everywhere he goes. And that’s a shame because the premise of him calling everyone out for being as violence-oriented as him is one of the most effective moments this season has pulled off.
The white supremacist universe thing has effectively become a gag by the end of the episode when it could have been a far more astute and thoughtful read on how easy it is for privileged classes to ignore heinous things when the environment favors them. Instead we’ve got the insistence that the Nazis won World War II without a remotely realistic setup on that end: This is not how the world would look if that had happened! There’s a reason that I was hoping we’d avoid the worldbuilding on that. Creating alternate universes is not a simple exercise when you follow a major historical change through to its conclusions. More importantly, allowing this all to exist in a cut-and-dry Nazi-verse ignores the very real and pressing white supremacist attitudes that exist in our own reality (and the prime DCU one, too), which are not all plain Nazism at their root.
Making white supremacy a fluffy little joke isn’t the move in our current environment, when all is said and done. It pulled all the breath out of a season that could have really honed in on its satirical premise.
The relative goodness of August Smith in this is also incredibly screwy when you’re effectively giving him the “hero in dark times” speech for the purpose of making Chris sad without acknowledging that the man is still standing by while horrific things are done to others. He claims not to be a Nazi, and it’s fine for him to say that he doesn’t agree with the ideology, but he’s not actually doing anything to combat it, as far as we’ve seen. And refusing to point that out unfortunately undercuts some of the very cool parallel work that’s happening here—specifically the fact that alt-Adrian manages to murder him, something that our own Adrian attempted last season and couldn’t pull off.
And then there’s Keith. Who we don’t know well enough to understand in this descent into hatred and potential obsession. I’m not saying I need to empathize with all his Nazi feelings, but I’m bothered by the fact that I have no idea what he’s objecting to in all of this. Did he truly love his brother? If so, it would’ve been nice to see it. Is he tired of always having to be the level-headed son? You might try bringing that up. Is the fact that his dad isn’t really down with Nazism a surprise to him? Because all of that seems important!
There are bright spots in the episode, however. Judomaster electrocuting the angry mob coming after Adebayo in the pool was gorgeous (particularly when you consider the racist history the U.S. has around Black people and swimming pools). Their bonding over Scrobble was adorable, as was Adebayo’s defense of Chris. It would have been nice to get a little more background in reverse, though. The other strong moment is Chris and Harcourt hightailing it away from A.R.G.U.S. on the Peacecycle, which might be the most effective long-arc of the season—going from Harcourt letting herself get beat up in bars alone to fighting alongside someone who cares about her, and finding a moment of comfort in fleeing together. It’s not the usual shades of romance you’re expecting, and that’s why it works.
Keeping the Peace (Thoughts and Asides)
Image: Jessica Miglio/HBO Max
The fact that August Smith’s primary concern is preventing anyone from finding out about the quantum door is actually the greatest indication of his character. He just wants to protect what’s his and leave everything else to the wolves.
There is a subtly clever bit of background here when compared to the comics: Once Peacemaker was acquired by DC, one of the main changes to his background was finding out that his father was an actual Nazi.
Look, at some point they need to explain to us where Adrian got those moves. It’s fun to watch him do flippy complex stuff, but where did it come from? It’s not like Chris taught him that.
My assumption is that Eagly brought Economos string because he assumes that being tied up was the man’s pathetic attempt at making a nest, and he’s trying to help.
And next week, the season comes to an end…[end-mark]
The post <i>Peacemaker</i> Creates New Villains in “Like a Keith in the Night” appeared first on Reactor.