www.newsbusters.org
WATCH: CNN Host Scoffs and Chuckles at Angel Mom Patty Morin
The White House press room was left speechless on Thursday after Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt invited Maryland angel mom Patty Morin to speak about her daughter Rachel, who was raped and murdered by an illegal immigrant (a story largely ignored by the liberal media until the briefing). But during Friday’s CNN This Morning, host Audie Cornish scoffed and chuckled at Morin as she chided the White House for their “use of the victims' families.”
Before writing off Morin’s story from discussions of illegal immigration, Cornish did play a soundbite of the grieving mother’s reaction to her Democratic Senator, Chris Van Hollen flying to El Salvador to be with an alleged MS-13 gang member instead of meeting with her:
And to have a senator from Maryland who didn't even acknowledge or barely acknowledged my daughter and the brutal death that she endured. [Transition] To fly to El Salvador to bring back someone that's not even an American citizen. Why does that person have more right than I do? Or my daughter?
But as she was noting that the cases were not directly related, Cornish couldn’t seem to help herself as she openly scoffed and chuckled.
“So, just to be clear, she was not raped or murdered by Kilmar Abrego Garcia. So, two completely different crimes [scoff and chuckle] different times,” she argued. “And Garcia does not actually have a criminal record.”
Looking to former Washington Senate candidate Tiffany Smiley (R), Cornish took issue with Morin’s story even being shared in this moment, suggesting that she was being “use[d]” by the White House. “And also, Tiffany, I want to hear from you about the use of the victims' families in this way, at the forefront. What do you make of having her out there in the response?” she asked.
But as Smiley was explaining how this was all about the White House’s response to illegal immigration, Cornish interrupted to question if Morin’s story should be included:
SMILEY: Well, I think it's important to hear Patty and Rachel's story. I mean, let's not --
CORNISH: But in this story?!
SMILEY: I mean, so -- so, I think this all goes back to the majority of Americans voted for President Trump, because there was an open Southern border where illegals were coming in and making our communities unsafe, killing American citizens with no plan in sight. And no -- no -- you know, people were feeling less and less safe with every waking day.
“And President Trump came in on a commitment -- promises made and promises kept -- that he was going to secure the border, deport illegals, deport criminals who do not belong in this country,” Smiley noted.
Cornish also took issue with Smiley talking about Garcia’s alleged criminal history, teaming up with former Obama official Nayyera Haq to push back (Click “expand”):
SMILEY: So, I think it's just making this stark contrast that, you know, this Maryland man, he is a part of MS-13. There is intelligence reports that show that he was involved in human trafficking. He’s a wife beater. There are records that his wife --
HAQ: None of that has actually been proven or shown in court. And that's part of the problem, is there's no due process.
[Crosstalk]
CORNISH: I know. I do want -- I'm glad you're introducing this. I also don't want to get sued, so I'll say the government has not released any documented information around intelligence reports, specifically. And right now, the documents they did release this week did not show he had a criminal record.
SMILEY: I think it is an interesting -- from a messaging --
CORNISH: Yes, I just want to say, "Fact."
“This is the conversation that I hear all the time, right? You're either for criminals, against victims; or you are for this bullying government that is just completely pillaging due process,” Cornish huffed, gesturing to her political guests.
The transcript is below. Click "expand" to read:
CNN This Morning
April 18, 2025
6:04:43 a.m. Eastern
(…)
AUDIE CORNISH: I want to play a sound bite, however, from Patty Morin. She's the mother of Rachel Morin, who was -- who was raped and murdered by an undocumented immigrant back in 2023. And here's how she reacted to Hollen's trip.
[Cuts to video]
PATTY MORIN (mother of Rachel Morin): And to have a senator from Maryland who didn't even acknowledge or barely acknowledged my daughter and the brutal death that she endured. [Transition] To fly to El Salvador to bring back someone that's not even an American citizen. Why does that person have more right than I do? Or my daughter?
[Cuts back to live]
CORNISH: So, just to be clear, she was not raped or murdered by Kilmar Abrego Garcia. So, two completely different crimes [scoffs and chuckles] different times. And Garcia does not actually have a criminal record.
But, Sara, I want to talk to you about messaging. And also, Tiffany, I want to hear from you about the use of the victims' families in this way, at the forefront. What do you make of having her out there in the response?
TIFFANY SMILEY (R, Washington Senate candidate): Well, I think it's important to hear Patty and Rachel's story. I mean, let's not --
CORNISH: But in this story?!
SMILEY: I mean, so -- so, I think this all goes back to the majority of Americans voted for President Trump, because there was an open Southern border where illegals were coming in and making our communities unsafe, killing American citizens with no plan in sight. And no -- no -- you know, people were feeling less and less safe with every waking day.
And President Trump came in on a commitment -- promises made and promises kept -- that he was going to secure the border, deport illegals, deport criminals who do not belong in this country.
So, I think it's just making this stark contrast that, you know, this Maryland man, he is a part of MS-13. There is intelligence reports that show that he was involved in human trafficking. He’s a wife beater. There are records that his wife --
NAYYERA HAQ (former Obama White House official): None of that has actually been proven or shown in court. And that's part of the problem, is there's no due process.
[Crosstalk]
CORNISH: I know. I do want -- I'm glad you're introducing this. I also don't want to get sued, so I'll say the government has not released any documented information around intelligence reports, specifically. And right now, the documents they did release this week did not show he had a criminal record.
SMILEY: I think it is an interesting -- from a messaging --
CORNISH: Yes, I just want to say, "Fact."
SMILEY: From a messaging standpoint, it's fascinating that Democrats are really going to bat for this illegal immigrant, which we do know he is. And that he --
HAQ (interrupting): He’s here legally. He had legal status here in the United States!
SMILEY: This senator is --
HAQ: If we're going to have the messaging conversation, let's at least make sure it’s grounded in the facts of individuals, because this is about people and human lives.
CORNISH: All right. Hold on, you guys. Let me bring in Sara for a minute.
SMILEY: Can I just say something real quick?
CORNISH: Hold on one second. This will be very fast. This is the conversation that I hear all the time, right? You're either for criminals, against victims; or you are for this bullying government that is just completely pillaging due process –
(…)